Featured categories
All items
Sorghum Molasses - 48oz
RM 88.79RM 118.41
Watermelon Rind Pickled
RM 41.20RM 54.95
Lime Pickles
RM 44.38RM 59.18
Spiced Peaches (in heavy syrup)
RM 53.89RM 71.87
Pure Raw Honey - 46oz
RM 158.59RM 211.47
Peanut Butter Taffy 16 oz
RM 60.24RM 80.33
Family Keepsakes Cookbook
RM 136.38RM 181.86
Sorghum Molasses - 24oz
RM 53.89RM 71.87
Wood Rolling Pin Amish Handmade - Large French Plain
RM 133.21RM 177.63
Whole Wheat Flour
RM 20.60RM 27.45
Oatmeal Cookie Mix
RM 50.72RM 67.64
CARAMELIZED SWEET ONION RELISH
RM 28.51RM 38.03
Huckleberry Taffy 16 oz
RM 60.24RM 80.33
Passion Fruit Jam
RM 34.86RM 46.49
Cinnamon Twist
RM 18.99RM 25.34
Sassafras Tea Concentrate
RM 31.68RM 42.26
Amish Homemade Lye Soap
RM 22.17RM 29.57
Wood Rolling Pin Amish Handmade (large 4 Tone)
RM 231.57RM 308.77
Peanut Butter 100% Natural, No Preservatives
RM 34.86RM 46.49
Pickled Garlic (Sweet) 18oz
RM 76.10RM 101.48
Popcorn Seasoning Buttery Salt
RM 44.38RM 59.18
Amish Popcorn White 5lb
RM 60.24RM 80.33
Wood Rolling Pin Amish Handmade (small 4 Tone)
RM 190.32RM 253.78
Kosher Dill Pickles Canning Mix ALL NATURAL
RM 44.38RM 59.18
World's Best Dish Cloths 12 pk
RM 126.87RM 169.17
Rainbow Popcorn - 5lb
RM 60.24RM 80.33
Dutch Blitz Card Game PURPLE Expansion Pack
RM 72.93RM 97.25
Elderberry Jelly
RM 31.68RM 42.26
World's Best Dish Cloths 3 pk
RM 47.55RM 63.41
Traffic Jam (Cherries, Rhubarb, Strawberries)
RM 34.86RM 46.49
Rolling Pin Amish Hand Made! (Large Speckled)
RM 263.29RM 351.07
Organic Whole Wheat Cream of Wheat 20 oz
RM 44.38RM 59.18
Mustard Eggs Pickled 11 eggs
RM 85.62RM 114.18
Sanded Ginger Drops
RM 28.51RM 38.03
Brussel Sprouts Mild Pickled
RM 41.20RM 54.95
Home Aromas Cookbook
RM 126.87RM 169.17
Pickled Beets
RM 44.38RM 59.18
Apple Cinnamon Jelly
RM 28.51RM 38.03
Pumpkin Butter
RM 34.86RM 46.49
Wood Rolling Pin Amish Handmade (small french style)
RM 120.52RM 160.71
Pure Raw Honey - 92oz
RM 317.23RM 422.99
SUGAR FREE Rootbeer Barrels - 8 oz
RM 28.51RM 38.03
Southwest Jalapeno Chili Noodles
RM 28.51RM 38.03
Peanut Butter Spread 17 oz
RM 44.38RM 59.18
Gummy Pigs
RM 47.55RM 63.41
Almond Flavoring
RM 22.17RM 29.57
Watermelon Twist
RM 18.99RM 25.34
Popcorn Sweet Kettle Corn White Hulless (Microwavable)
RM 88.79RM 118.41
About us
The Amish Trading Post is your connection to the Amish communities in Missouri. Founded in 2014, the Amish Trading Post has become the center for the local Amish sell to their fresh, local, handmade and homemade items. Some of the most popular products have always been the seasonal jams and jellies, pickles, and baked goods, as well as unique handmade furniture and household items, such as cutting boards and noodle cutters. New items arrive weekly, and it is always exciting to see what's new at The Amish Trading Post! These items are now available to YOU! Our valued online customers are welcome to order these items without a trip to rural Missouri.
Seller feedback (782)
- t***o (762)- Feedback left by buyer.Past 6 monthsVerified purchaseThis seller is very fair and the products are high quality. A shipping issue arose and the seller responded immediately, resolving the issue.
- _***w (183)- Feedback left by buyer.Past monthVerified purchaseQuick shipping. Item was well wrapped and enclosed in a plastic bag, which was good because the lid leaked. Without the bag, it would have been a big mess!
- w***g (2816)- Feedback left by buyer.Past 6 monthsVerified purchaseItem as described, fast shipping, A great eBayer! Recommended +++++
- 2***0 (2263)- Feedback left by buyer.Past 6 monthsVerified purchaseExcellent quality dog biscuits. Good value. Well packaged; seller shipped fast. Thank you.
- a***n (607)- Feedback left by buyer.Past 6 monthsVerified purchaseShipped fast, well packaged, arrived in perfect condition. Would buy from this seller again.
- i***i (100)- Feedback left by buyer.Past yearVerified purchaseGood price and fast shipping. Great transaction