ReviewsAny summary of the sections [of this book] cannot possibly do justice to the richness of the discussion so concisely presented. While it is true that the focus of much of the book is primarily on the individuals who made up the elite in China - precisely because the assumption generally has been that their secularization was ahead of that of the masses - the outlook is even so not a narrow one, extending as it does at times beyond the Han Chinese to the margins of China. In an increasingly crowded market, this is a volume that stands out., "Taking head-on the widespread conviction that modernity entails secularization, Paul Katz shows how selected members of the Chinese elite in the first half of the twentieth century adapted their faith to modernity in the pursuit of traditional religious activities like charity, printed propagation of the faith, and spirit writing."-John Lagerwey, author of China: A Religious State, "Any summary of the sections [of this book] cannot possibly do justice to the richness of the discussion so concisely presented. While it is true that the focus of much of the book is primarily on the individuals who made up the elite in China precisely because the assumption generally has been that their secularization was ahead of that of the masses the outlook is even so not a narrow one, extending as it does at times beyond the Han Chinese to the margins of China. In an increasingly crowded market, this is a volume that stands out."- China Quarterly, China-watchers used to think there was traditional China and its religion, then Maoism, then a secular globalized society. Katz debunks this view, by focusing on the first modernity: both religion and its discontents were key parts of modernization processes all along., "Any summary of the sections [of this book] cannot possibly do justice to the richness of the discussion so concisely presented. While it is true that the focus of much of the book is primarily on the individuals who made up the elite in China - precisely because the assumption generally has been that their secularization was ahead of that of the masses - the outlook is even so not a narrow one, extending as it does at times beyond the Han Chinese to the margins of China. In an increasingly crowded market, this is a volume that stands out." -China Quarterly, " Katz's exploration of the religious life of the Chinese elite stands as a much-needed reminder of the limited success of China's secularizing elites in their attempts to transform Chinese culture."-David Ownby, Université de Montréal, The book is successful in demonstrating that educated elites, who were part of the development of modernity and industry in China, were also committed to various forms of religious cultivation, religiously based philanthropy, religious publishing, and the defense of certain forms of religion that were under threat from other elites throughout the period. The book thus helps to nuance our understanding of China's transition to modernity, by demonstrating the lingering importance of religion throughout the period, which is otherwise known for campaign after campaign targeting temples and superstitious practices., "Katz's exploration of the religious life of the Chinese elite stands as a much-needed reminder of the limited success of China's secularizing elites in their attempts to transform Chinese culture."-David Ownby, Université de Montréal, "China-watchers used to think there was traditional China and its religion, then Maoism, then a secular globalized society. Katz debunks this view, by focusing on the first modernity: both religion and its discontents were key parts of modernization processes all along."-Vincent Goossaert, coauthor of The Religious Question in Modern China,, Meticulously researched. . . . Paul R. Katz argues that modernization in China did not lead to a decline of religion, but rather to a change in religious life notably the lack of direct state participation in religion., Katz's study of religious innovation challenges narratives of Chinese religious conservatism and decline, and its mapping of elite religious activity overturns conventional depictions of the secularism of China's leading modernizers., "Katz's study of religious innovation challenges narratives of Chinese religious conservatism and decline, and its mapping of elite religious activity overturns conventional depictions of the secularism of China's leading modernizers."-David Palmer, coauthor of The Religious Question in Modern China,, "Katz's study of religious innovation challenges narratives of Chinese religious conservatism and decline, and its mapping of elite religious activity overturns conventional depictions of the secularism of China's leading modernizers."-David Palmer, coauthor of The Religious Question in Modern China, Taking head-on the widespread conviction that modernity entails secularization, Paul Katz shows how selected members of the Chinese elite in the first half of the twentieth century adapted their faith to modernity in the pursuit of traditional religious activities like charity, printed propagation of the faith, and spirit writing., "China-watchers used to think there was traditional China and its religion, then Maoism, then a secular globalized society. Katz debunks this view, by focusing on the first modernity: both religion and its discontents were key parts of modernization processes all along."-Vincent Goossaert, coauthor of The Religious Question in Modern China
Target AudienceScholarly & Professional