Skip to main content
eBay Logo

Shop by category

Advanced
    • Daily Deals
    • Help & Contact
    • Sell
    • My eBayExpand My eBay
      • Summary
      • Recently Viewed
      • Bids/Offers
      • Watch List
      • Purchase History
      • Selling
      • Saved Searches
      • Saved Sellers
      • Messages

    There seems to be a problem serving the request at this time

    breadcrumb

    • eBay
      • Sporting Goods
      • Sports Mem, Cards & Fan Shop
    • Sporting Goods
    • Sports Mem, Cards & Fan Shop
    • Autographs-Original
    • Robert Mathis Indianapolis Colts Original Sports Autographed Items

    Robert Mathis Indianapolis Colts Original Sports Autographed Items

    Side Refine Panel

    Shop by Category

    • Sports Mem, Cards & Fan Shop
    • Autographs-Original
    • Baseball-MLB
    • Basketball-NBA
    • Basketball-WNBA
    • Boxing
    • College-NCAA
    • Display Cases
    • Football-NFL
    • Golf-LPGA
    • Golf-PGA
    • Golf-Other
    • Hockey-NHL
    • Hockey-Other
    • Mixed Martial Arts (MMA)
    • Olympics
    • Racing-Formula 1
    • Racing-NASCAR
    • Racing-NHRA
    • Racing-Other
    • Rugby
    • Soccer
      • Tennis
      • Wrestling
      • Other Autographed Sports Mem

    • All

    • Auction

    • Buy It Now

    • Best Match
    • Time: Ending soonest
    • Time: Newly listed
    • Price + Postage: lowest first
    • Price + Postage: highest first
    • Distance: nearest first
    • List View

    46 Results

      • Team: Indianapolis Colts filter applied
      • Player: Robert Mathis filter applied
      Clear All
      • Indianapolis Colts filter applied
      • Robert Mathis filter applied
      • All Listings filter applied
    • Robert Mathis Indianapolis Colts Signed Custom Jersey JSA Authenticated

      Robert Mathis Indianapolis Colts Signed Custom Jersey JSA Authenticated

      RM 481.83
      RM 136.20 shipping
      or Best Offer
      SPONSORED
    • Robert Mathis Signed Indianapolis Colts Jersey (JSA COA) Super Bowl XLI Champ DE

      Robert Mathis Signed Indianapolis Colts Jersey (JSA COA) Super Bowl XLI Champ DE

      RM 839.67
      RM 135.18 shipping
      SPONSORED
    • Robert Mathis Signed Indianapolis Colts Jersey (JSA COA) Super Bowl XLI Champ LB

      Robert Mathis Signed Indianapolis Colts Jersey (JSA COA) Super Bowl XLI Champ LB

      RM 972.29
      RM 137.17 shipping
      SPONSORED
    • Robert Mathis Signed Indianapolis Colts Pro Bowl Custom Style Jersey (JSA COA)

      Robert Mathis Signed Indianapolis Colts Pro Bowl Custom Style Jersey (JSA COA)

      RM 795.47
      RM 134.52 shipping
      SPONSORED
    • Indianapolis Colts Robert Mathis Autographed Pro Style White Jersey JSA Authe...

      Indianapolis Colts Robert Mathis Autographed Pro Style White Jersey JSA Authe...

      RM 526.04
      RM 178.32 shipping
      or Best Offer
      4 watching
    • Robert Mathis Indianapolis Colts autographed NFL football proof Beckett COA

      Robert Mathis Indianapolis Colts autographed NFL football proof Beckett COA

      RM 530.42
      RM 138.63 shipping
      or Best Offer
    • Robert Mathis Hand Signed Autographed Indianapolis Colts 11x14 Photo w/ JSA COA

      Robert Mathis Hand Signed Autographed Indianapolis Colts 11x14 Photo w/ JSA COA

      RM 234.20
      RM 96.46 shipping
      or Best Offer
    • Robert Mathis Signed Indianapolis Colts Jersey (JSA COA) Super Bowl XLI Champion

      Robert Mathis Signed Indianapolis Colts Jersey (JSA COA) Super Bowl XLI Champion

      RM 353.42
      0 bids
      RM 124.97 shipping
      Ending Apr 5 at 8:35AM MYT4d 17h
    • Indianapolis Colts Robert Mathis Autographed Pro Style Grey Jersey JSA Authen...

      Indianapolis Colts Robert Mathis Autographed Pro Style Grey Jersey JSA Authen...

      RM 526.04
      RM 178.32 shipping
      or Best Offer
    • Robert Mathis Signed Indianapolis Colts TD Football Pylon Proof of Autograph COA

      Robert Mathis Signed Indianapolis Colts TD Football Pylon Proof of Autograph COA

      RM 574.53
      RM 181.24 shipping
      or Best Offer
    • Robert Mathis Signed Indianapolis Colts Jersey (JSA COA) Super Bowl XLI Champion

      Robert Mathis Signed Indianapolis Colts Jersey (JSA COA) Super Bowl XLI Champion

      RM 707.06
      RM 133.19 shipping
    • Robert Mathis Signed Indianapolis Colts Jersey (JSA COA) Super Bowl Champion XLI

      Robert Mathis Signed Indianapolis Colts Jersey (JSA COA) Super Bowl Champion XLI

      RM 751.26
      RM 133.85 shipping
      or Best Offer
    • ROBERT MATHIS SIGNED INDIANAPOLIS COLTS FOOTBALL 8x10 PHOTO #1 AUTOGRAPH PROOF!

      ROBERT MATHIS SIGNED INDIANAPOLIS COLTS FOOTBALL 8x10 PHOTO #1 AUTOGRAPH PROOF!

      RM 104.51
      RM 49.00 shipping
      or Best Offer
    • 2022 Robert Mathis Signed Indianapolis Pro Blue Football Jersey

      2022 Robert Mathis Signed Indianapolis Pro Blue Football Jersey

      RM 530.42
      RM 108.21 shipping
      or Best Offer
      SPONSORED
    • Robert Mathis Autographed/Signed Jersey JSA COA Indianapolis Colts

      Robert Mathis Autographed/Signed Jersey JSA COA Indianapolis Colts

      RM 461.94
      Was: RM 486.25
      RM 184.42 shipping
      SPONSORED
    • Robert Mathis Signed Indianapolis Colts Custom Blue Jersey - Mathis/Radtke COA

      Robert Mathis Signed Indianapolis Colts Custom Blue Jersey - Mathis/Radtke COA

      RM 663.03
      RM 192.07 shipping
    • Robert Mathis Signed Indianapolis Custom Blue Jersey w/SB XLI Champs

      Robert Mathis Signed Indianapolis Custom Blue Jersey w/SB XLI Champs

      RM 707.24
      RM 185.44 shipping
      or Best Offer
    • Robert Mathis Autographed 8x10 Indianapolis Colts NFL

      Robert Mathis Autographed 8x10 Indianapolis Colts NFL

      RM 110.47
      RM 102.38 shipping
      or Best Offer
    • Robert Mathis Signed Indianapolis Colts Speed Authentic Flash NFL Helmet

      Robert Mathis Signed Indianapolis Colts Speed Authentic Flash NFL Helmet

      RM 2,652.25
      RM 334.85 shipping
      or Best Offer
    • Robert Mathis Signed Indianapolis Colts Speed Authentic Camo NFL Helmet

      Robert Mathis Signed Indianapolis Colts Speed Authentic Camo NFL Helmet

      RM 2,652.25
      RM 334.85 shipping
      or Best Offer
    • Robert Mathis Signed Indianapolis Custom Blue Jersey

      Robert Mathis Signed Indianapolis Custom Blue Jersey

      RM 618.83
      RM 184.11 shipping
      or Best Offer
    • Robert Mathis Signed Indianapolis Custom White Jersey w/SB XLI Champs

      Robert Mathis Signed Indianapolis Custom White Jersey w/SB XLI Champs

      RM 707.24
      RM 185.44 shipping
      or Best Offer
    • Robert Mathis Signed Indianapolis Custom White Jersey w/52 Forced Fumbles

      Robert Mathis Signed Indianapolis Custom White Jersey w/52 Forced Fumbles

      RM 707.24
      RM 185.44 shipping
      or Best Offer
    • ROBERT MATHIS SIGNED AUTOGRAPHED 8x10 FOOTBALL PHOTO BECKETT BAS COA PRO BOWL

      ROBERT MATHIS SIGNED AUTOGRAPHED 8x10 FOOTBALL PHOTO BECKETT BAS COA PRO BOWL

      RM 220.98
      RM 66.26 shipping
      or Best Offer
    • ROBERT MATHIS COLTS SIGNED AUTOGRAPHED 8X10 NFL FOOTBALL PHOTO-BECKETT BAS COA

      ROBERT MATHIS COLTS SIGNED AUTOGRAPHED 8X10 NFL FOOTBALL PHOTO-BECKETT BAS COA

      RM 220.98
      RM 66.26 shipping
      or Best Offer
    • Robert Mathis Signed Indianapolis Colts Speed Lunar NFL Mini Helmet

      Robert Mathis Signed Indianapolis Colts Speed Lunar NFL Mini Helmet

      RM 574.62
      RM 108.17 shipping
      or Best Offer
    • Robert Mathis Signed Indianapolis Colts Speed Authentic Eclipse NFL Helmet

      Robert Mathis Signed Indianapolis Colts Speed Authentic Eclipse NFL Helmet

      RM 2,652.25
      RM 334.85 shipping
      or Best Offer
    • EMMITT THOMAS KANSAS CITY CHIEFS SIGNED LUNAR MINI HELMET JSA

      EMMITT THOMAS KANSAS CITY CHIEFS SIGNED LUNAR MINI HELMET JSA

      RM 397.84
      RM 180.84 shipping
      or Best Offer
    • Robert Mathis Signed Indianapolis Colts Speed Authentic NFL Helmet - Inscription

      Robert Mathis Signed Indianapolis Colts Speed Authentic NFL Helmet - Inscription

      RM 2,342.82
      RM 330.21 shipping
      or Best Offer
    • ROBERT MATHIS SBXLI CHAMPS INDIANAPOLIS COLTS SIGNED MINI HELMET JSA

      ROBERT MATHIS SBXLI CHAMPS INDIANAPOLIS COLTS SIGNED MINI HELMET JSA

      RM 397.84
      RM 180.84 shipping
      or Best Offer
    • Robert Mathis Signed Indianapolis Colts Speed Authentic NFL Helmet - Inscription

      Robert Mathis Signed Indianapolis Colts Speed Authentic NFL Helmet - Inscription

      RM 2,342.82
      RM 330.21 shipping
      or Best Offer
    • Robert Mathis Signed Indianapolis Custom Blue Jersey w/52 Forced Fumbles

      Robert Mathis Signed Indianapolis Custom Blue Jersey w/52 Forced Fumbles

      RM 707.24
      RM 185.44 shipping
      or Best Offer
    • Robert Mathis Signed Indianapolis Custom White Jersey

      Robert Mathis Signed Indianapolis Custom White Jersey

      RM 618.83
      RM 184.11 shipping
      or Best Offer
    • Robert Mathis Signed Indianapolis Colts Speed Eclipse NFL Mini Helmet

      Robert Mathis Signed Indianapolis Colts Speed Eclipse NFL Mini Helmet

      RM 618.83
      RM 108.83 shipping
      or Best Offer
    • Robert Mathis Signed Indianapolis Colts Speed NFL Mini Helmet w/Colt 4 Life!

      Robert Mathis Signed Indianapolis Colts Speed NFL Mini Helmet w/Colt 4 Life!

      RM 618.83
      RM 108.83 shipping
      or Best Offer
    • Robert Mathis Signed Indianapolis Colts Speed NFL Mini Helmet w/SB XLI Champs

      Robert Mathis Signed Indianapolis Colts Speed NFL Mini Helmet w/SB XLI Champs

      RM 618.83
      RM 108.83 shipping
      or Best Offer
    • Robert Mathis Signed Indianapolis Colts Speed Full Size Flash NFL Helmet

      Robert Mathis Signed Indianapolis Colts Speed Full Size Flash NFL Helmet

      RM 1,547.13
      RM 318.28 shipping
      or Best Offer
    • Robert Mathis Signed Indianapolis Colts Speed Full Size Eclipse NFL Helmet

      Robert Mathis Signed Indianapolis Colts Speed Full Size Eclipse NFL Helmet

      RM 1,768.15
      RM 321.59 shipping
      or Best Offer
    • Mathis and Freeney Signed Indianapolis Colts Speed Authentic NFL Helmet

      Mathis and Freeney Signed Indianapolis Colts Speed Authentic NFL Helmet

      RM 2,784.87
      RM 336.84 shipping
      or Best Offer
      2 watching
    • Robert Mathis Signed Indianapolis Colts Speed Authentic NFL Helmet

      Robert Mathis Signed Indianapolis Colts Speed Authentic NFL Helmet

      RM 1,989.18
      RM 324.91 shipping
      or Best Offer
    • ROBERT MATHIS SBXLI CHAMPS INDIANAPOLIS COLTS SIGNED MINI HELMET JSA COA

      ROBERT MATHIS SBXLI CHAMPS INDIANAPOLIS COLTS SIGNED MINI HELMET JSA COA

      RM 353.60
      RM 127.88 shipping
    • *ROBERT MATHIS*SIGNED*AUTOGRAPHED*FOOTBALL*INDIANAPOLIS*COLTS*COA*

      *ROBERT MATHIS*SIGNED*AUTOGRAPHED*FOOTBALL*INDIANAPOLIS*COLTS*COA*

      RM 481.83
      RM 383.04 shipping
      or Best Offer
    • *ROBERT MATHIS*SIGNED*AUTOGRAPHED*FOOTBALL*INDIANAPOLIS*COLTS*COA*

      *ROBERT MATHIS*SIGNED*AUTOGRAPHED*FOOTBALL*INDIANAPOLIS*COLTS*COA*

      RM 526.04
      RM 383.04 shipping
      or Best Offer
    • Robert Mathis Signed Indianapolis Colts Embroidered White Football - Inscription

      Robert Mathis Signed Indianapolis Colts Embroidered White Football - Inscription

      RM 707.24
      RM 185.44 shipping
      or Best Offer
    • Robert Mathis Signed Indianapolis Colts Speed Full Size NFL Helmet

      Robert Mathis Signed Indianapolis Colts Speed Full Size NFL Helmet

      RM 1,215.59
      RM 301.43 shipping
      or Best Offer
      2 watching
    • Robert Mathis Signed Indianapolis Colts 11x14 Photo JSA

      Robert Mathis Signed Indianapolis Colts 11x14 Photo JSA

      RM 220.98
      RM 80.81 shipping
      or Best Offer
    • Robert Mathis Signed Indianapolis Colts 11x14 Photo JSA

      Robert Mathis Signed Indianapolis Colts 11x14 Photo JSA

      RM 220.98
      RM 103.79 shipping
      or Best Offer
    • Robert Mathis Signed Custom Indianapolis Colts Jersey JSA COA

      Robert Mathis Signed Custom Indianapolis Colts Jersey JSA COA

      RM 884.05
      RM 119.93 shipping
      or Best Offer

    Additional site navigation

    • About eBay
    • Community
    • Security Centre
    • Seller Central
    • Policies
    • Help & Contact
    • Site Map
    Copyright © 1995-2023 eBay Inc. All Rights Reserved. User Agreement, Privacy, Payments Terms of Use, Cookies and AdChoice