Professional Sports Authenticator (PSA) Indianapolis Colts Football NFL Original Autographed Items for sale

Peyton Manning Signed Stitched On Field Reebok Indianapolis Colts Jersey PSA/DNA
RM 3,384.76
or Best Offer
RM 239.81 shipping
Reggie Wayne Signed Indianapolis Colts 16x20 Photo PSA
RM 951.98
or Best Offer
RM 130.27 shipping
Peyton Manning Autographed Inscribed “2014 MVP” Framed 16x20 Photo Colts PSA
RM 1,840.44
or Best Offer
RM 546.39 shipping
Graded 2012 Panini Prizm Andrew Luck #203 Turned Sideway RC Football Card PSA 10
RM 628.30
or Best Offer
RM 93.17 shipping
Peyton Manning Signed Indianapolis Colts Mitchell & Ness Jersey PSA COA RARE
RM 4,230.96
or Best Offer
RM 288.00 shipping
Peyton Manning Signed Rookie 8x10 Color Photo - PSA/DNA 10 GEM MINT AUTO ! - WOW
RM 1,903.95
RM 181.26 shipping
JIM IRSAY SIGNED MINT CUT PSA/DNA AUTOGRAPHED NFL INDIANAPOLIS COLTS OWNER
RM 423.06
RM 87.12 shipping
Peyton Manning Signed 2006 Topps Card PSA/DNA Slabbed AUTHENTIC AUTOGRAPH Auto
RM 528.88
or Best Offer
RM 110.09 shipping
Andrew Luck Signed Indianapolis Colts 8x10 Photo Autographed PSA/DNA COA
RM 317.28
or Best Offer
RM 107.64 shipping
Pat McAfee Signed Autographed Pylon Indianapolis Colts Psa/Dna Coa
RM 2,115.46
or Best Offer
RM 293.38 shipping
PEYTON MANNING AUTOGRAPHED JERSEY PSA/DNA COA (AUTHENTIC REEBOK ON-FIELD) WOW!🔥
IN PERSON AT HOF CERMONY WITH INSCPTIONS AND HOF PATCH!
RM 706.32
RM 1,084.32 shipping
23 bids
4d 15h
Anthony Richardson Auto - Signed Colts - Speed Flash Authentic NFL Helmet - PSA
RM 1,774.06
Was: RM 2,534.37was - RM 2,534.37
or Best Offer
RM 280.73 shipping
Pat McAfee Signed Autographed Indianapolis Colts Jersey Football PSA/DNA
RM 2,115.46
or Best Offer
RM 310.98 shipping
PEYTON MANNING SIGNED AUTOGRAPH FULL SIZE FOOTBALL - INDIANAPOLIS COLTS STAR PSA
RM 3,384.59
or Best Offer
RM 197.04 shipping
ANDREW LUCK SIGNED AUTOGRAPHED INDIANAPOLIS COLTS FOOTBALL ART PAINTING PSA/DNA
RM 2,115.46
or Best Offer
RM 351.09 shipping
PEYTON MANNING #18 SIGNED INDIANAPOLIS COLTS MITCHELL & NESS JERSEY PSA/DNA
RM 4,230.96
or Best Offer
RM 259.02 shipping
Pat McAfee Signed Autographed Indianapolis Colts Jersey Football PSA/DNA
RM 2,115.46
or Best Offer
RM 310.98 shipping
Dominic Rhodes Signed Indianapolis Colts 8x10 Photo (PSA COA)
RM 148.04
RM 81.53 shipping
4 watching
Tom Moore Signed Photo PSA Indianapolis Colts
RM 169.20
or Best Offer
RM 79.63 shipping
Reggie Wayne Signed Colts Eclipse Helmet Full Size Authentic - PSA
RM 1,586.63
or Best Offer
RM 350.75 shipping
PSA/DNA Indianapolis #18 Peyton Manning Signed Colts Authentic Puma Jersey HOF
RM 4,230.79
or Best Offer
RM 317.66 shipping
Peyton Manning Signed AUTO Photo SB XLI MVP inscrip Colts FB HOF Steiner PSA/DNA
RM 1,586.63
or Best Offer
RM 159.47 shipping
Johnny Unitas 12/30/99 Signed Check PSA/DNA #85155102 Slabbed EX MINT Auto
RM 380.75
or Best Offer
RM 136.45 shipping
Daniel Jones Signed Autographed Indianapolis Colts Full Size Helmet PSA/DNA COA
RM 1,269.26
or Best Offer
RM 340.81 shipping
ANDREW LUCK Autographed Colts 16" X 20" "12" Photograph PANINI LE 1/25
RM 2,030.84
or Best Offer
1995 Skybox Marshall Faulk Signed PSA Authentic Autograph Indianapolis Colts
RM 431.39
Was: RM 507.51was - RM 507.51
or Best Offer
RM 87.37 shipping
Peyton Manning Signed PSA /DNA GEM 10 AUTO - BEAUTY !! COLTS
RM 1,269.30
RM 148.47 shipping
HOFers PEYTON MANNING and MARVIN HARRISON signed INDIANAPOLIS COLTS Football PSA
RM 1,205.84
or Best Offer
RM 306.11 shipping
Peyton Manning Signed First Day Cover 2006 Touch Down Record Harrison PSA/DNA
RM 1,480.81
or Best Offer
RM 150.41 shipping
Pat McAfee Signed Autographed 1/1 11x14 Photo Indianapolis Colts Psa/Dna Coa FTB
RM 2,115.29
or Best Offer
RM 181.89 shipping
Pat McAfee Signed Wilson NFL Football Autographed ESPN Colts PSA/DNA
RM 1,480.81
or Best Offer
RM 288.17 shipping
Dwight Freeney signed 2002 Topps Rookie Card RC IP auto PSA 9 Colts
RM 528.88
or Best Offer
RM 90.25 shipping
Peyton & Archie Manning Signed 16x20 Framed Photo PSA Colts Saints LE 74/100
RM 2,961.66
or Best Offer
RM 331.24 shipping
Tony Dungy Indianapolis Colts Signed 8X10 Photo Autographed PSA/DNA COA W43370
RM 135.35
RM 66.60 shipping
PEYTON MANNING INDIANAPOLIS COLTS SIGNED AUTHOGRAPHED JERSEY AUTHENTIC COA
RM 1,459.70
or Best Offer
RM 292.36 shipping
10 watching
Autographed Frank Gore Indianapolis Colts Jersey - PSA Authentic
RM 575.42
or Best Offer
RM 206.18 shipping
PEYTON MANNING Signed/autographed Jersey Indianapolis Colts PSA
RM 2,961.70
or Best Offer
RM 164.54 shipping
Reggie Wayne Indianapolis Colts Signed Autographed Mini helmet Salute to SERV
RM 549.99
or Best Offer
RM 131.46 shipping
Edgerrin James signed autographed Colts authentic Puma game model jersey PSA/DNA
RM 1,692.36
RM 201.69 shipping
ANDREW LUCK SIGNED INDIANAPOLIS COLTS FOOTBALL ARTWORK ORGINAL PAINTING PSA/DNA
RM 2,115.46
or Best Offer
RM 351.09 shipping
Pat McAfee Signed Baseball PSA/DNA For The Brand WWE Colts Legend Autographed
RM 507.68
or Best Offer
RM 89.61 shipping
Dwight Freeney Signed Indianapolis Colts Jersey PSA DNA Coa Autographed
RM 529.30
Was: RM 588.11was - RM 588.11
or Best Offer
RM 124.10 shipping
Marlon Mack Signed 2017 Panini Prizm Silver RC IP Auto PSA/DNA Colts
RM 253.82
or Best Offer
RM 102.26 shipping
PAT McAFEE Autographed AUTHENTIC Nike On-Field COLTS Jersey PSA COA NFL LOA sz48
RM 4,209.89
or Best Offer
RM 329.43 shipping
14 watching
Andrew Luck & Peyton Manning Signed 16x20 Photo Autograph Colts PSA/DNA Fanatics
RM 5,500.26
or Best Offer
RM 299.60 shipping
Reggie Wayne Signed Blue Custom Player Jersey "Forever A Colt" PSA 539
RM 761.54
or Best Offer
RM 189.84 shipping
PEYTON MANNING SIGNED INDIANAPOLIS COLTS PROMO PHOTO SLABBED PSA/DNA COA AUTO
RM 1,269.26
or Best Offer
RM 154.39 shipping
Peyton Manning Signed (September 3rd 2007) Sports Illustrated Magazine PSA/DNA
RM 2,443.36
or Best Offer
RM 149.23 shipping
Carson Wentz Signed Official NFL Colts Team Issued Game Football Psa Dna Coa
RM 757.77
Was: RM 841.97was - RM 841.97
or Best Offer
RM 162.98 shipping
Dwight Clark Signed AUTO Photo The Catch Hand drawn Play CSA show ticket PSA/DNA
RM 2,094.35
or Best Offer
RM 136.41 shipping
Carson Wentz Indianapolis Colts Autographed NFL Authentic "The Duke Football"
RM 719.23
RM 287.37 shipping
COLTS- DWIGHT FREENEY AUTOGRAPH 8x10 SPORTS ILLUSTRATED COVER PHOTO PSA AM76160
RM 253.65
or Best Offer
RM 103.28 shipping
Jim Harbaugh Colts Autographed Signed 1997 Skybox Impact Card#135 PSA Slab Auth.
RM 338.44
RM 109.96 shipping
Tony Dungy Indianapolis Colts Signed 8X10 Photo Autographed PSA/DNA COA Y34
RM 152.27
RM 67.10 shipping
Peyton Manning Signed Autographed Authentic 2004 Colts Pro Bowl Jersey PSA COA
RM 4,759.83
Was: RM 5,288.71was - RM 5,288.71
or Best Offer
RM 241.72 shipping
Tony Dungy Indianapolis Colts Signed 8X10 Photo Autographed PSA/DNA COA W49773
RM 126.89
RM 66.34 shipping
Dwight Freeney Signed 2002 Score RC IP Auto PSA/DNA Indianapolis Colts
RM 507.68
or Best Offer
RM 109.75 shipping
ANDREW LUCK Signed STANFORD Mini Helmet-INDIANAPOLIS COLTS-PSA
RM 962.51
Was: RM 1,480.81was - RM 1,480.81
RM 147.87 shipping
Colts T.Y. Hilton Signed Framed 11x14 Photo PSA COA
RM 423.06
or Best Offer
RM 366.83 shipping
Indianapolis Colts ROH Bobblehead Lot Of 3 Dwight Freeney Robert Mathis Glenn
RM 486.57
or Best Offer
RM 229.40 shipping

Professional Sports Authenticator (PSA) Indianapolis Colts Football NFL Original Autographed Items

Shop by category

305 results

Peyton Manning Signed Stitched On Field Reebok Indianapolis Colts Jersey PSA/DNA

Reggie Wayne Signed Indianapolis Colts 16x20 Photo PSA

Peyton Manning Autographed Inscribed “2014 MVP” Framed 16x20 Photo Colts PSA

Graded 2012 Panini Prizm Andrew Luck #203 Turned Sideway RC Football Card PSA 10

Peyton Manning Signed Indianapolis Colts Mitchell & Ness Jersey PSA COA RARE

Peyton Manning Signed Rookie 8x10 Color Photo - PSA/DNA 10 GEM MINT AUTO ! - WOW

JIM IRSAY SIGNED MINT CUT PSA/DNA AUTOGRAPHED NFL INDIANAPOLIS COLTS OWNER

Peyton Manning Signed 2006 Topps Card PSA/DNA Slabbed AUTHENTIC AUTOGRAPH Auto

Andrew Luck Signed Indianapolis Colts 8x10 Photo Autographed PSA/DNA COA

Pat McAfee Signed Autographed Pylon Indianapolis Colts Psa/Dna Coa

PEYTON MANNING AUTOGRAPHED JERSEY PSA/DNA COA (AUTHENTIC REEBOK ON-FIELD) WOW!🔥

Anthony Richardson Auto - Signed Colts - Speed Flash Authentic NFL Helmet - PSA

Pat McAfee Signed Autographed Indianapolis Colts Jersey Football PSA/DNA

PEYTON MANNING SIGNED AUTOGRAPH FULL SIZE FOOTBALL - INDIANAPOLIS COLTS STAR PSA

ANDREW LUCK SIGNED AUTOGRAPHED INDIANAPOLIS COLTS FOOTBALL ART PAINTING PSA/DNA

PEYTON MANNING #18 SIGNED INDIANAPOLIS COLTS MITCHELL & NESS JERSEY PSA/DNA

Pat McAfee Signed Autographed Indianapolis Colts Jersey Football PSA/DNA

Dominic Rhodes Signed Indianapolis Colts 8x10 Photo (PSA COA)

Tom Moore Signed Photo PSA Indianapolis Colts

Reggie Wayne Signed Colts Eclipse Helmet Full Size Authentic - PSA

PSA/DNA Indianapolis #18 Peyton Manning Signed Colts Authentic Puma Jersey HOF

Peyton Manning Signed AUTO Photo SB XLI MVP inscrip Colts FB HOF Steiner PSA/DNA

Johnny Unitas 12/30/99 Signed Check PSA/DNA #85155102 Slabbed EX MINT Auto

Daniel Jones Signed Autographed Indianapolis Colts Full Size Helmet PSA/DNA COA

ANDREW LUCK Autographed Colts 16" X 20" "12" Photograph PANINI LE 1/25

1995 Skybox Marshall Faulk Signed PSA Authentic Autograph Indianapolis Colts

Peyton Manning Signed PSA /DNA GEM 10 AUTO - BEAUTY !! COLTS

HOFers PEYTON MANNING and MARVIN HARRISON signed INDIANAPOLIS COLTS Football PSA

Peyton Manning Signed First Day Cover 2006 Touch Down Record Harrison PSA/DNA

Pat McAfee Signed Autographed 1/1 11x14 Photo Indianapolis Colts Psa/Dna Coa FTB

Pat McAfee Signed Wilson NFL Football Autographed ESPN Colts PSA/DNA

Dwight Freeney signed 2002 Topps Rookie Card RC IP auto PSA 9 Colts

Peyton & Archie Manning Signed 16x20 Framed Photo PSA Colts Saints LE 74/100

Tony Dungy Indianapolis Colts Signed 8X10 Photo Autographed PSA/DNA COA W43370

PEYTON MANNING INDIANAPOLIS COLTS SIGNED AUTHOGRAPHED JERSEY AUTHENTIC COA

Autographed Frank Gore Indianapolis Colts Jersey - PSA Authentic

PEYTON MANNING Signed/autographed Jersey Indianapolis Colts PSA

Reggie Wayne Indianapolis Colts Signed Autographed Mini helmet Salute to SERV

Edgerrin James signed autographed Colts authentic Puma game model jersey PSA/DNA

ANDREW LUCK SIGNED INDIANAPOLIS COLTS FOOTBALL ARTWORK ORGINAL PAINTING PSA/DNA

Pat McAfee Signed Baseball PSA/DNA For The Brand WWE Colts Legend Autographed

Dwight Freeney Signed Indianapolis Colts Jersey PSA DNA Coa Autographed

Marlon Mack Signed 2017 Panini Prizm Silver RC IP Auto PSA/DNA Colts

PAT McAFEE Autographed AUTHENTIC Nike On-Field COLTS Jersey PSA COA NFL LOA sz48

Andrew Luck & Peyton Manning Signed 16x20 Photo Autograph Colts PSA/DNA Fanatics

Reggie Wayne Signed Blue Custom Player Jersey "Forever A Colt" PSA 539

PEYTON MANNING SIGNED INDIANAPOLIS COLTS PROMO PHOTO SLABBED PSA/DNA COA AUTO

Peyton Manning Signed (September 3rd 2007) Sports Illustrated Magazine PSA/DNA

Carson Wentz Signed Official NFL Colts Team Issued Game Football Psa Dna Coa

Dwight Clark Signed AUTO Photo The Catch Hand drawn Play CSA show ticket PSA/DNA

Carson Wentz Indianapolis Colts Autographed NFL Authentic "The Duke Football"

COLTS- DWIGHT FREENEY AUTOGRAPH 8x10 SPORTS ILLUSTRATED COVER PHOTO PSA AM76160

Jim Harbaugh Colts Autographed Signed 1997 Skybox Impact Card#135 PSA Slab Auth.

Tony Dungy Indianapolis Colts Signed 8X10 Photo Autographed PSA/DNA COA Y34

Peyton Manning Signed Autographed Authentic 2004 Colts Pro Bowl Jersey PSA COA

Tony Dungy Indianapolis Colts Signed 8X10 Photo Autographed PSA/DNA COA W49773

Dwight Freeney Signed 2002 Score RC IP Auto PSA/DNA Indianapolis Colts

ANDREW LUCK Signed STANFORD Mini Helmet-INDIANAPOLIS COLTS-PSA

Colts T.Y. Hilton Signed Framed 11x14 Photo PSA COA

Indianapolis Colts ROH Bobblehead Lot Of 3 Dwight Freeney Robert Mathis Glenn