Pro Set Football Indianapolis Colts Original Sports Trading Card Singles

Shop by category

Sports Trading Cards

2,654 results

SSP #’d /10 AUTO RC 2023 Leaf Pro Set Pure Autographs Anthony Richardson Rookie
Pre-Owned · Pro Set
RM 416.42
or Best Offer
RM 93.09 shipping
Eric Dickerson 1990 Pro Set Football Pro Bowl SP Error Donald Igwebuike Back
Pre-Owned · Pro Set
RM 125.98
RM 74.33 shipping
2025 Pro Set Metal Surname Signatures Silver Prismatic Auto 2/5 Peyton Manning
Pre-Owned · Leaf
RM 98.85
RM 88.29 shipping
17 bids
2d 5h
2025 Pro Set Metal Base Blue Prismatic 5/25 Ulysses Bentley IV #156 Colts
Pre-Owned · Pro Set
RM 4.16
RM 73.95 shipping
0 bids
3d 8h
1990 Pro Set Official NFL Card Series II 2 Factory Sealed Unopened Full Box NEW
Pre-Owned · Pro Set
RM 105.16
RM 96.32 shipping
0 bids
5d 10h
2022 Leaf Pro Set Jojo Domann SP Gold Parallel Auto Rookie RC #PSA-JD1 Colts
Pre-Owned · Pro Set
RM 4.16
RM 67.93 shipping
0 bids
3d 12h
New ListingEric Dickerson Pro Set 1991 Indianapolis Colts - Autographed In Person
Pre-Owned · Pro Set
RM 54.64
RM 69.11 shipping
B4670- 1988 Pro Set Test #3 Eric Dickerson - PSA NrMt+ (7.5)
New (Other) · Pro Set
RM 124.86
RM 75.08 shipping
Eric Dickerson Pro Bowl 1990 Pro Set Colts #338 SHORT PRINT Wrong Back Rare NM+
Pre-Owned · Pro Set
RM 1,051.53
or Best Offer
RM 127.96 shipping
1990 Pro Set Jeff George Colts Draft Day - BLANK BACK BRONZE BORDER - Scarce
Pre-Owned · Pro Set
RM 16.78
RM 80.63 shipping
0 bids
1d 11h
New Listing1989 Pro Set - Keith Bostic #456
Pre-Owned · Pro Set
RM 6.52
or Best Offer
RM 62.42 shipping
1990 Pro Set Jeff George Falcons Draft Day - BLANK BACK BRONZE BORDER - Scarce
Pre-Owned · Pro Set
RM 16.78
RM 84.84 shipping
0 bids
1d 11h
1991 Pro Set Eric Dickerson #175 Indianapolis Colts
Pre-Owned
RM 6.57
or Best Offer
RM 36.65 shipping
1 of 1 SSP Anthony Richardson Auto 2023 MEATAL Pro Set CAMPUS VIP 1/1 WATER PSA
New (Other) · Pro Set
RM 1,257.68
or Best Offer
RM 130.90 shipping
ANTHONY RICHARDSON ROOKIE AUTO Card 2023 Pro Set Metal RARE/5 BLACK MOJO PSA 7
New (Other)
RM 294.40
RM 91.95 shipping
2022 Pro Set Metal Autograph PA-AR1 Anthony Richardson RC Rookie AUTO 12/15 Colt
Pre-Owned · Leaf
RM 588.67
RM 79.63 shipping
1990 Pro Set Jeff George/Keith McCants Draft Day Set BLANK FRONT GOLD BORDER
Pre-Owned · Pro Set
RM 20.99
RM 79.50 shipping
0 bids
1d 11h
1993 Pro Set ROOSEVELT POTTS Indianapolis Colts Rookie Running Backs Prism Card
Pre-Owned · Pro Set
RM 8.37
or Best Offer
RM 68.06 shipping
0 bids
8h 9m
1989 Pro Set Eric Dickerson Indianapolis Colts #455
Pre-Owned
RM 4.13
or Best Offer
RM 24.46 shipping
1990 NFL Pro-Set Collect A Books Football Jeff George - NM-MT
Pre-Owned · Pro Set
RM 6.27
RM 67.68 shipping
0 bids
5d 1h
2022 Leaf Metal Draft Anthony Richardson State Pride Rookie Auto SSP 2/5 Colts
Pre-Owned · Leaf
RM 336.29
RM 96.37 shipping
1991 Pro Set Pat Beach Indianapolis Colts #524
Pre-Owned
RM 3.03
or Best Offer
RM 13.45 shipping
2023 Leaf Pro Set Metal Printing Plate Anthony Richardson Rookie #70 1/1 RC
Pre-Owned · Pro Set
RM 117.73
RM 84.42 shipping
Eric Dickerson Pro Bowl-1990 Pro Set series-Colts #338 SHORT PRINT Rare
Pre-Owned
RM 315.43
RM 81.39 shipping
1991 Pro Set Eugene Daniel Indianapolis Colts #526
Pre-Owned
RM 3.03
or Best Offer
RM 13.45 shipping
1991 Pro Set Eugene Daniel Indianapolis Colts #38
Pre-Owned
RM 3.03
or Best Offer
RM 13.45 shipping
Jeff George 1990 Pro Set #1 Pick SP Error Miscut W/ Sheet Proof Strip Colts #669
Pre-Owned · Pro Set
RM 125.98
RM 74.33 shipping
2023 Pro Set Pure Anthony Richardson Action Ink Sparkle Clear 1/5 Auto Colts
Pre-Owned
RM 315.47
RM 92.58 shipping
(2) 1990 Pro Set JEFF GEORGE Colts #1 Draft Pick Photo Variation Cards #669
Pre-Owned · Pro Set
RM 20.82
or Best Offer
RM 62.88 shipping
1990 Pro Set Error Football (Don Griffin Front, Eric Dickerson Miscut on Back)
Pre-Owned · Pro Set
RM 210.10
or Best Offer
RM 68.44 shipping
Eric Dickerson Pro Bowl-1990 Pro Set series-Colts #338 SHORT PRINT
Pre-Owned · Pro Set
RM 252.38
or Best Offer
RM 90.10 shipping
35 watching
1990 Pro Set Jeff George #669 (COLTS UNIFORM) PSA 9 MINT (LOW POP) (ROOKIE CARD)
New (Other) · Pro Set
RM 206.11
or Best Offer
RM 97.54 shipping
Eric Dickerson 1990 Pro Set Pro Bowl SP Error Red Wash Blank Front Rare!!
Pre-Owned · Pro Set
RM 117.57
RM 65.70 shipping
17 watching
Joe Montana 1990 Pro Set Error Back Print Ghost Image Over Clarence Verdin
Pre-Owned
RM 210.10
RM 76.81 shipping
Anthony Richardson 2023 Pro Set Metal Football
Pre-Owned · Pro Set
RM 210.32
or Best Offer
RM 87.45 shipping
1990 Pro Set JEFF GEORGE RC #669 - Indianapolis Colts - 1990 #1 Draft Pick
Pre-Owned · Pro Set
RM 4.16
or Best Offer
RM 8.41 shipping
0 bids
4d 12h
B4670- 1988 Pro Set Test #3 Eric Dickerson - PSA NrMt+ (7.5)
New (Other) · Pro Set
RM 124.95
RM 75.15 shipping
2023 Leaf Pro Set Metal Anthony Richardson LIT AUTO #5/10 Jersey Match COLTS
Pre-Owned · Pro Set
RM 630.73
RM 111.97 shipping
$2023 Leaf Pro Set Metal Autographs #PA-JD1 Josh Downs Auto Refractor 14/25 - Image 1 of 2$
2023 Leaf Pro Set Metal Autographs #PA-JD1 Josh Downs Auto Refractor 14/25
Pre-Owned · Pro Set
RM 273.41
or Best Offer
RM 139.61 shipping
1991 Pro Set Platinum #201 JEFF HERROD Indianapolis Colts Football Card, LB (NM)
Pre-Owned · Pro Set
RM 4.16
RM 66.54 shipping
2022 Leaf Pro Set Anthony Richardson ZEBRA Wave AUTO RC Rookie #4/5 PA-AR1
Pre-Owned · Pro Set
RM 210.27
or Best Offer
RM 68.44 shipping
Excellent: Vintage 1990 PRO SET Eugene Daniel Indianapolis Colts Trading Card
Pre-Owned · Pro Set
RM 0.84
or Best Offer
RM 65.58 shipping
0 bids
2d 19h
2023 Pro Set Metal Anthony Richardson Goin Pro Auto-blue Pulsar Psa 10 COLTS QB
New (Other)
RM 504.76
or Best Offer
RM 95.44 shipping
1988 Pro Set Test Set Eric Dickerson PSA 9
New (Other) · Pro Set
RM 273.41
RM 99.77 shipping
1991 Pro Set Rohn Stark Indianapolis Colts #428
Pre-Owned
RM 3.03
RM 13.45 shipping
JEFF GEORGE 1992 PRO LINE PROFILES CERTIFIED AUTO INDIANAPOLIS COLTS
Pre-Owned · Pro Set
RM 63.05
RM 85.14 shipping
1991 Pro Set Pat Beach Indianapolis Colts #524
Pre-Owned
RM 3.03
or Best Offer
RM 13.45 shipping
1991 Pro Set Chip Banks Indianapolis Colts #523
Pre-Owned
RM 3.03
RM 13.45 shipping
1989 Pro Set Chris Hinton Indianapolis Colts #163
Pre-Owned
RM 3.06
or Best Offer
RM 24.46 shipping
New ListingTREVOR ETIENNE 2024 Leaf Metal PRO SET Rookie Sealed MASTERPIECE Proof Card 1/1
Pre-Owned · Pro Set
RM 20.99
RM 83.87 shipping
0 bids
4d 12h
1991 Pro Set Clarence Verdin Indianapolis Colts #430
Pre-Owned
RM 3.03
RM 13.45 shipping
1988 Pro Set Test Eric Dickerson #3 PSA 7 HOF
Fulfilled by COMC - World’s largest consignment service
New (Other)
RM 388.03
RM 98.89 shipping
1990 Pro Set Chris Hinton Indianapolis Colts #343
Pre-Owned
RM 3.06
or Best Offer
RM 24.46 shipping
1990 Pro Set Chris Hinton #343C
Pre-Owned
RM 4.21
RM 7.99 shipping
1990 Pro Set Clarence Verdin Indianapolis Colts #137
Pre-Owned
RM 3.06
or Best Offer
RM 24.46 shipping
1990 Pro Set Ken Clark Rookie Indianapolis Colts #751
Pre-Owned
RM 3.06
or Best Offer
RM 24.46 shipping
1991 Pro Set Sam Clancy Indianapolis Colts #525
Pre-Owned
RM 3.03
RM 13.45 shipping
2024 Leaf Pro Set Goin Pro Gold Super Prismatic Proof Adonai Mitchell Rookie 1/1
Pre-Owned
RM 105.12
RM 65.37 shipping
1992 Pro Set Power #171 KEVIN CALL Auto Autographed HAND SIGNED Football Card
Pre-Owned · Pro Set
RM 16.78
or Best Offer
RM 68.31 shipping
1990 PRO SET JEFF GEORGE RC INDIANAPOLIS COLTS #669B 031222BB
RM 4.16
RM 66.54 shipping

Pro Set Football Indianapolis Colts Original Sports Trading Card Singles

Shop by category

2,654 results

SSP #’d /10 AUTO RC 2023 Leaf Pro Set Pure Autographs Anthony Richardson Rookie

Eric Dickerson 1990 Pro Set Football Pro Bowl SP Error Donald Igwebuike Back

2025 Pro Set Metal Surname Signatures Silver Prismatic Auto 2/5 Peyton Manning

2025 Pro Set Metal Base Blue Prismatic 5/25 Ulysses Bentley IV #156 Colts

1990 Pro Set Official NFL Card Series II 2 Factory Sealed Unopened Full Box NEW

2022 Leaf Pro Set Jojo Domann SP Gold Parallel Auto Rookie RC #PSA-JD1 Colts

New ListingEric Dickerson Pro Set 1991 Indianapolis Colts - Autographed In Person

B4670- 1988 Pro Set Test #3 Eric Dickerson - PSA NrMt+ (7.5)

Eric Dickerson Pro Bowl 1990 Pro Set Colts #338 SHORT PRINT Wrong Back Rare NM+

1990 Pro Set Jeff George Colts Draft Day - BLANK BACK BRONZE BORDER - Scarce

New Listing1989 Pro Set - Keith Bostic #456

1990 Pro Set Jeff George Falcons Draft Day - BLANK BACK BRONZE BORDER - Scarce

1991 Pro Set Eric Dickerson #175 Indianapolis Colts

1 of 1 SSP Anthony Richardson Auto 2023 MEATAL Pro Set CAMPUS VIP 1/1 WATER PSA

ANTHONY RICHARDSON ROOKIE AUTO Card 2023 Pro Set Metal RARE/5 BLACK MOJO PSA 7

2022 Pro Set Metal Autograph PA-AR1 Anthony Richardson RC Rookie AUTO 12/15 Colt

1990 Pro Set Jeff George/Keith McCants Draft Day Set BLANK FRONT GOLD BORDER

1993 Pro Set ROOSEVELT POTTS Indianapolis Colts Rookie Running Backs Prism Card

1989 Pro Set Eric Dickerson Indianapolis Colts #455

1990 NFL Pro-Set Collect A Books Football Jeff George - NM-MT

2022 Leaf Metal Draft Anthony Richardson State Pride Rookie Auto SSP 2/5 Colts

1991 Pro Set Pat Beach Indianapolis Colts #524

2023 Leaf Pro Set Metal Printing Plate Anthony Richardson Rookie #70 1/1 RC

Eric Dickerson Pro Bowl-1990 Pro Set series-Colts #338 SHORT PRINT Rare

1991 Pro Set Eugene Daniel Indianapolis Colts #526

1991 Pro Set Eugene Daniel Indianapolis Colts #38

Jeff George 1990 Pro Set #1 Pick SP Error Miscut W/ Sheet Proof Strip Colts #669

2023 Pro Set Pure Anthony Richardson Action Ink Sparkle Clear 1/5 Auto Colts

(2) 1990 Pro Set JEFF GEORGE Colts #1 Draft Pick Photo Variation Cards #669

1990 Pro Set Error Football (Don Griffin Front, Eric Dickerson Miscut on Back)

Eric Dickerson Pro Bowl-1990 Pro Set series-Colts #338 SHORT PRINT

1990 Pro Set Jeff George #669 (COLTS UNIFORM) PSA 9 MINT (LOW POP) (ROOKIE CARD)

Eric Dickerson 1990 Pro Set Pro Bowl SP Error Red Wash Blank Front Rare!!

Joe Montana 1990 Pro Set Error Back Print Ghost Image Over Clarence Verdin

Anthony Richardson 2023 Pro Set Metal Football

1990 Pro Set JEFF GEORGE RC #669 - Indianapolis Colts - 1990 #1 Draft Pick

B4670- 1988 Pro Set Test #3 Eric Dickerson - PSA NrMt+ (7.5)

2023 Leaf Pro Set Metal Anthony Richardson LIT AUTO #5/10 Jersey Match COLTS

2023 Leaf Pro Set Metal Autographs #PA-JD1 Josh Downs Auto Refractor 14/25

1991 Pro Set Platinum #201 JEFF HERROD Indianapolis Colts Football Card, LB (NM)

2022 Leaf Pro Set Anthony Richardson ZEBRA Wave AUTO RC Rookie #4/5 PA-AR1

Excellent: Vintage 1990 PRO SET Eugene Daniel Indianapolis Colts Trading Card

2023 Pro Set Metal Anthony Richardson Goin Pro Auto-blue Pulsar Psa 10 COLTS QB

1988 Pro Set Test Set Eric Dickerson PSA 9

1991 Pro Set Rohn Stark Indianapolis Colts #428

JEFF GEORGE 1992 PRO LINE PROFILES CERTIFIED AUTO INDIANAPOLIS COLTS

1991 Pro Set Pat Beach Indianapolis Colts #524

1991 Pro Set Chip Banks Indianapolis Colts #523

1989 Pro Set Chris Hinton Indianapolis Colts #163

New ListingTREVOR ETIENNE 2024 Leaf Metal PRO SET Rookie Sealed MASTERPIECE Proof Card 1/1

1991 Pro Set Clarence Verdin Indianapolis Colts #430

1988 Pro Set Test Eric Dickerson #3 PSA 7 HOF

1990 Pro Set Chris Hinton Indianapolis Colts #343

1990 Pro Set Chris Hinton #343C

1990 Pro Set Clarence Verdin Indianapolis Colts #137

1990 Pro Set Ken Clark Rookie Indianapolis Colts #751

1991 Pro Set Sam Clancy Indianapolis Colts #525

2024 Leaf Pro Set Goin Pro Gold Super Prismatic Proof Adonai Mitchell Rookie 1/1

1992 Pro Set Power #171 KEVIN CALL Auto Autographed HAND SIGNED Football Card

1990 PRO SET JEFF GEORGE RC INDIANAPOLIS COLTS #669B 031222BB