New York Yankees 1991 Season Sports Trading Cards & Accessories

Shop by category

Sports Mem, Cards & Fan Shop

30,925 results

New Listing1991 Score MICKEY MANTLE Promo Set of 7 #4013 of 5000 PSA Graded -Details Below!
RM 841.17
RM 121.15 shipping
0 bids
6d 21h
New Listing1991 Topps Desert Shield #285 JIM ABBOTT PSA 8 ANGELS
New (Other) · Topps
RM 316.81
RM 92.44 shipping
1992 Donruss Baseball Complete UPDATE SET #1-22– Kenny Lofton -SEE DESCRIPTION!
Pre-Owned · Donruss
RM 845.36
or Best Offer
RM 124.65 shipping
1991 Babe Ruth New York Yankees MINI Baseball Card
Pre-Owned
RM 4.18
or Best Offer
RM 66.91 shipping
0 bids
23m 32s
New ListingDon Mattingly 1991 Leaf #425 New York Yankees FREE SHIPPING AutographDen
Pre-Owned
RM 0.04
RM 76.09 shipping
0 bids
9d 22h
New Listing1991 Topps Baseball Wax Box 36 Sealed Packs - Possible Chipper Jones RC?
Brand New · Topps
RM 190.22
or Best Offer
RM 173.52 shipping
0 bids
6d 16h
1991 FLEER #673 DON MATTINGLY YANKEES PSA 9
4SC: Leading the industry in consignment services!
New (Other)
RM 42.23
RM 92.91 shipping
1 bid
5d 23h
1991 Bowman Baseball Factory Sealed Complete Set 704 Cards!
Brand New · Bowman
RM 4.18
RM 176.27 shipping
1 bid
2h 3m
PSA 10 Rickey Henderson 1991 Topps #670, Oakland Athletics, A's, NY Yankees, HOF
New (Other) · Topps
RM 126.81
RM 66.28 shipping
0 bids
2d 23h
New ListingG2-22 CARL EVERETT NEW YORK YANKEES 1990 BOWMAN #156 PSA GRADED MINT 9
New (Other) · Bowman
RM 105.46
or Best Offer
RM 90.84 shipping
1991 Bowman Carl Everett #156 Yankees ROOKIE RC - Advanced 9 MINT
New (Other) · Bowman
RM 4.18
or Best Offer
RM 83.82 shipping
0 bids
1h 46m
1991 Score - Mark Leiter #727 (RC)
Pre-Owned · SCORE
RM 2.54
or Best Offer
RM 65.77 shipping
0 bids
1d 23h
PSA 10 Rickey Henderson 1991 Bowman #213, Oakland Athletics, A's, NY Yankees HOF
New (Other) · Topps
RM 105.68
RM 65.69 shipping
1 bid
2d 23h
1991 Upper Deck Baseball Factory Sealed Box Find the Nolan (STRAIGHT FROM CASE)
RM 253.58
RM 168.36 shipping
27 watching
1/1 CHIPPER JONES RC 💎 1991 TOPPS ROOKIE SSP 💎 NEW PENINI: ONE OF ONE ART
Pre-Owned · Topps
RM 845.36
or Best Offer
RM 112.82 shipping
11 watching
New Listing1991 Classic Draft Picks Card #1 Future Superstars Larry Johnson Eric Lindros NM
Pre-Owned · Classic Games
RM 992.42
or Best Offer
RM 90.25 shipping
New ListingROOKIE CARD HOF'er MIKE MUSSINA Orioles 1991 Leaf GOLD LEAF ROOKIES INSERT #BC12
Pre-Owned · Leaf
RM 29.55
RM 67.63 shipping
0 bids
9d 22h
New Listing1991 Upper Deck “Find The Nolan” Baseball Sealed Box Michael Jordan SP Rookie
Brand New · Upper Deck
RM 211.35
RM 221.28 shipping
0 bids
6d 21h
1991 TOPPS #100 DON MATTINGLY YANKEES 101 HITS IN 1990 PSA 10
The #1 consignment choice on eBay: 4SC! Consign now!
New (Other)
RM 86.65
RM 94.39 shipping
4 bids
1d 23h
1991 SCORE #386 CARL EVERETT RC YANKEES PSA 10
Get unbeatable industry-low consignment rates at 4SC!
New (Other)
RM 42.23
RM 92.91 shipping
0 bids
5d 23h
1991 Donruss - Bonus Cards Andy Hawkins #BC-12 "No-Hits White Sox"
Pre-Owned · Donruss
RM 845.40
or Best Offer
RM 93.08 shipping
1991 Donruss - Rated Rookie Hensley Meulens #31 One Yellow Line Right Border
Pre-Owned · Leaf
RM 1.06
RM 66.83 shipping
0 bids
2d 20h
Original 1991 topps desert shield #359 Chuck Cary New York Yankees
Pre-Owned · Topps
RM 21.09
RM 70.59 shipping
0 bids
18h 41m
New ListingDon Mattingly New York Yankees 1991 Gold Border 91G-4
Pre-Owned
RM 21.09
or Best Offer
RM 12.68 shipping
1991 Upper Deck - Deion Sanders #352
Pre-Owned · Upper Deck
RM 1.06
or Best Offer
RM 65.73 shipping
0 bids
5d 21h
1991 UPPER DECK STAR ROOKIE #11 BERNIE WILLIAMS PSA 10 YANKEES
New (Other) · Upper Deck
RM 253.58
RM 89.49 shipping
1991 Bowman - Carl Everett #156 (RC)
New (Other) · Topps
RM 26.33
or Best Offer
RM 88.60 shipping
0 bids
1d 23h
New Listing1991 Swell Baseball Greats #90 Luis Tiant
Pre-Owned
RM 10.57
RM 67.04 shipping
M & M Boys Mickey Mantle & Roger Maris 1991 Set 30th Anniversary CARD Low number
Pre-Owned
RM 1,268.10
RM 99.97 shipping
New Listing1992 Stadium Club Dome #58 Jason Giambi New York Yankees
Pre-Owned
RM 11.79
RM 62.90 shipping
🔥1991 STAR CO. MILLENNIUM KEVIN MAAS SET ONLY 200 SETS W/Promo💥EBAY POP 1 MLB
Pre-Owned · The Star Co.
RM 845.36
or Best Offer
RM 119.62 shipping
🔥1991 STAR CO. MILLENNIUM DON MATTINGLY SET ONLY 200 SETS W/Promo💥Ebay POP 1
Pre-Owned · The Star Co.
RM 1,268.06
or Best Offer
RM 132.09 shipping
1991 TOPPS CARL EVERETT ROOKIE #1 DRAFT PICK #113 BGS 8.5
New (Other) · Topps
RM 63.36
RM 85.51 shipping
0 bids
2d
New Listing1991 Topps - Don Mattingly #100 Operation Desert Shield
Pre-Owned · Topps
RM 528.38
RM 96.08 shipping
1 bid
6d 10h
New Listing1991 Impel/Line Drive Mattingly #9 Don Mattingly PSA 10 GEM MT
New (Other) · Impel
RM 422.66
RM 75.03 shipping
Yogi Berra 1991 Topps Archives 1953 #104 New York Yankees
Pre-Owned · Topps
RM 8.41
or Best Offer
RM 68.05 shipping
0 bids
2d 13h
1991 Fleer Don Mattingly New York Yankees #673
Pre-Owned
RM 3.03
or Best Offer
RM 13.45 shipping
BB - 1991 Topps Tiffany - #379 - Randy Velarde - PSA 10 - GEM MT
New (Other) · Topps
RM 249.39
or Best Offer
RM 91.01 shipping
1991 score baseball cards trivia
Pre-Owned · SCORE
RM 169.08
or Best Offer
RM 155.60 shipping
Mickey Mantle WORN JERSEY CARD 2022 JERSEY FUSION 1991 FANTASY CAMP NY YANKEES
Pre-Owned · Leaf
RM 422.49
RM 75.03 shipping
$2021 #255 Aaron Judge Topps Stadium Club Chrome Refractor 1991 Throw Back 🔥 - Image 1 of 2$
2021 #255 Aaron Judge Topps Stadium Club Chrome Refractor 1991 Throw Back 🔥
Pre-Owned · Topps
RM 80.27
or Best Offer
RM 70.51 shipping
New Listing1991 Score Baseball Collector Set 900 Cards MLB FACTORY SEALED
Brand New · SCORE
RM 8.45
RM 188.52 shipping
0 bids
6d 23h
1991 UPPER DECK #65 MIKE MUSSINA TOP PROSPECT RC PSA 10 ORIOLES HOF
New (Other) · Upper Deck
RM 147.90
RM 86.36 shipping
MARIANO RIVERA 2025 Leaf 15th National NSCC Anniversary 1991 #91B-111 #'d 5/15
Pre-Owned · Leaf
RM 21.09
or Best Offer
RM 71.44 shipping
0 bids
5d 23h
RANDY JOHNSON 2025 Leaf 15th National NSCC Anniversary 1991 #91B-136 #'d 5/7
Pre-Owned · Leaf
RM 21.09
or Best Offer
RM 71.44 shipping
0 bids
5d 23h
New Listing1991 Topps Traded Baseball Card Set 1T-132T - Unsealed
Pre-Owned · Topps
RM 32.93
or Best Offer
RM 95.36 shipping
1991 Fleer Pro-Visions Don Mattingly “Mr. Yankee” CSG 9 Free Shipping
New (Other) · Fleer
RM 211.35
RM 68.77 shipping
1991 DONRUSS ROBERTO KELLY NEW YORK YANKEES #400
Pre-Owned
RM 3.82
RM 15.29 shipping
1991 Upper Deck - Tim Leary #693
Pre-Owned · Upper Deck
RM 4.23
or Best Offer
RM 68.27 shipping
0 bids
4d
New Listing1991 Leaf Baseball Series 2 Wax Box 📦 Factory Sealed – 36 Packs MLB Stars RC-k
Brand New · Leaf
RM 63.19
or Best Offer
RM 118.65 shipping
0 bids
6d 22h
1991 Topps Archives The Ultimate 1953 Set - Ralph Houk #282
Pre-Owned · Topps
RM 4.23
or Best Offer
RM 81.33 shipping
0 bids
3d 23h
1991 Fleer Pro-Visions — Don Mattingly — “Mr. Yankee” — MINT PSA 9
New (Other) · Fleer
RM 507.24
or Best Offer
RM 98.66 shipping
1991 Tuff Stuff #LP7 Brien Taylor Rookie On Card Auto SP /2500 New York Yankees
Pre-Owned
RM 147.95
or Best Offer
RM 89.95 shipping
New ListingBob Geren 1991 Topps #716 New York Yankees Baseball Card
Pre-Owned · Topps
RM 5.33
or Best Offer
RM 8.45 shipping
1991 Topps - Don Mattingly #100 Operation Desert Shield
New (Other) · Topps
RM 1,420.27
RM 125.58 shipping
0 bids
1d 23h
New Listing1991 Fleer - Don Mattingly #673
Pre-Owned · Fleer
RM 0.04
RM 72.37 shipping
0 bids
6d 15h
1991 TOPPS ALL-STAR ROOKIE #642 HAL MORRIS PSA 10 REDS YANKEES LOW POP
New (Other) · Topps
RM 295.85
or Best Offer
RM 90.71 shipping
1991 Topps Carl Everett #113 Rookie Card RC #1 Draft Pick New York Yankees
Pre-Owned · Topps
RM 4.18
RM 67.97 shipping
0 bids
5d 23h
🔥1991 STAR CO. PLATINUM DON MATTINGLY SET ONLY 200 SETS W/Promo💥Ebay POP 1
Pre-Owned · The Star Co.
RM 845.36
or Best Offer
RM 119.62 shipping
FIND THE HANK! 1991 Upper Deck High Series Baseball Factory Sealed Hobby Box
Brand New · Upper Deck
RM 232.27
or Best Offer
RM 216.72 shipping
35 watching

New York Yankees 1991 Season Sports Trading Cards & Accessories

Shop by category

30,925 results

New Listing1991 Score MICKEY MANTLE Promo Set of 7 #4013 of 5000 PSA Graded -Details Below!

New Listing1991 Topps Desert Shield #285 JIM ABBOTT PSA 8 ANGELS

1992 Donruss Baseball Complete UPDATE SET #1-22– Kenny Lofton -SEE DESCRIPTION!

1991 Babe Ruth New York Yankees MINI Baseball Card

New ListingDon Mattingly 1991 Leaf #425 New York Yankees FREE SHIPPING AutographDen

New Listing1991 Topps Baseball Wax Box 36 Sealed Packs - Possible Chipper Jones RC?

1991 FLEER #673 DON MATTINGLY YANKEES PSA 9

1991 Bowman Baseball Factory Sealed Complete Set 704 Cards!

PSA 10 Rickey Henderson 1991 Topps #670, Oakland Athletics, A's, NY Yankees, HOF

New ListingG2-22 CARL EVERETT NEW YORK YANKEES 1990 BOWMAN #156 PSA GRADED MINT 9

1991 Bowman Carl Everett #156 Yankees ROOKIE RC - Advanced 9 MINT

1991 Score - Mark Leiter #727 (RC)

PSA 10 Rickey Henderson 1991 Bowman #213, Oakland Athletics, A's, NY Yankees HOF

1991 Upper Deck Baseball Factory Sealed Box Find the Nolan (STRAIGHT FROM CASE)

1/1 CHIPPER JONES RC 💎 1991 TOPPS ROOKIE SSP 💎 NEW PENINI: ONE OF ONE ART

New Listing1991 Classic Draft Picks Card #1 Future Superstars Larry Johnson Eric Lindros NM

New ListingROOKIE CARD HOF'er MIKE MUSSINA Orioles 1991 Leaf GOLD LEAF ROOKIES INSERT #BC12

New Listing1991 Upper Deck “Find The Nolan” Baseball Sealed Box Michael Jordan SP Rookie

1991 TOPPS #100 DON MATTINGLY YANKEES 101 HITS IN 1990 PSA 10

1991 SCORE #386 CARL EVERETT RC YANKEES PSA 10

1991 Donruss - Bonus Cards Andy Hawkins #BC-12 "No-Hits White Sox"

1991 Donruss - Rated Rookie Hensley Meulens #31 One Yellow Line Right Border

Original 1991 topps desert shield #359 Chuck Cary New York Yankees

New ListingDon Mattingly New York Yankees 1991 Gold Border 91G-4

1991 Upper Deck - Deion Sanders #352

1991 UPPER DECK STAR ROOKIE #11 BERNIE WILLIAMS PSA 10 YANKEES

1991 Bowman - Carl Everett #156 (RC)

New Listing1991 Swell Baseball Greats #90 Luis Tiant

M & M Boys Mickey Mantle & Roger Maris 1991 Set 30th Anniversary CARD Low number

New Listing1992 Stadium Club Dome #58 Jason Giambi New York Yankees

🔥1991 STAR CO. MILLENNIUM KEVIN MAAS SET ONLY 200 SETS W/Promo💥EBAY POP 1 MLB

🔥1991 STAR CO. MILLENNIUM DON MATTINGLY SET ONLY 200 SETS W/Promo💥Ebay POP 1

1991 TOPPS CARL EVERETT ROOKIE #1 DRAFT PICK #113 BGS 8.5

New Listing1991 Topps - Don Mattingly #100 Operation Desert Shield

New Listing1991 Impel/Line Drive Mattingly #9 Don Mattingly PSA 10 GEM MT

Yogi Berra 1991 Topps Archives 1953 #104 New York Yankees

1991 Fleer Don Mattingly New York Yankees #673

BB - 1991 Topps Tiffany - #379 - Randy Velarde - PSA 10 - GEM MT

1991 score baseball cards trivia

Mickey Mantle WORN JERSEY CARD 2022 JERSEY FUSION 1991 FANTASY CAMP NY YANKEES

2021 #255 Aaron Judge Topps Stadium Club Chrome Refractor 1991 Throw Back 🔥

New Listing1991 Score Baseball Collector Set 900 Cards MLB FACTORY SEALED

1991 UPPER DECK #65 MIKE MUSSINA TOP PROSPECT RC PSA 10 ORIOLES HOF

MARIANO RIVERA 2025 Leaf 15th National NSCC Anniversary 1991 #91B-111 #'d 5/15

RANDY JOHNSON 2025 Leaf 15th National NSCC Anniversary 1991 #91B-136 #'d 5/7

New Listing1991 Topps Traded Baseball Card Set 1T-132T - Unsealed

1991 Fleer Pro-Visions Don Mattingly “Mr. Yankee” CSG 9 Free Shipping

1991 DONRUSS ROBERTO KELLY NEW YORK YANKEES #400

1991 Upper Deck - Tim Leary #693

New Listing1991 Leaf Baseball Series 2 Wax Box 📦 Factory Sealed – 36 Packs MLB Stars RC-k

1991 Topps Archives The Ultimate 1953 Set - Ralph Houk #282

1991 Fleer Pro-Visions — Don Mattingly — “Mr. Yankee” — MINT PSA 9

1991 Tuff Stuff #LP7 Brien Taylor Rookie On Card Auto SP /2500 New York Yankees

New ListingBob Geren 1991 Topps #716 New York Yankees Baseball Card

1991 Topps - Don Mattingly #100 Operation Desert Shield

New Listing1991 Fleer - Don Mattingly #673

1991 TOPPS ALL-STAR ROOKIE #642 HAL MORRIS PSA 10 REDS YANKEES LOW POP

1991 Topps Carl Everett #113 Rookie Card RC #1 Draft Pick New York Yankees

🔥1991 STAR CO. PLATINUM DON MATTINGLY SET ONLY 200 SETS W/Promo💥Ebay POP 1

FIND THE HANK! 1991 Upper Deck High Series Baseball Factory Sealed Hobby Box

More to explore