Skip to main content
eBay Logo

Shop by category

Advanced
    • Daily Deals
    • Help & Contact
    • Sell
    • My eBayExpand My eBay
      • Summary
      • Recently Viewed
      • Bids/Offers
      • Watch List
      • Purchase History
      • Selling
      • Saved Searches
      • Saved Sellers
      • Messages
    {"delay":300}

    There seems to be a problem serving the request at this time

    breadcrumb

    • eBay
      • Sporting Goods
      • Sports Mem, Cards & Fan Shop
    • Sporting Goods
    • Sports Mem, Cards & Fan Shop
    • Autographs-Original
    • Indianapolis Colts Not Authenticated Original Sports Autographed Items

    Indianapolis Colts Not Authenticated Original Sports Autographed Items

    Side Refine Panel

    Shop by Category

    • Sports Mem, Cards & Fan Shop
    • Autographs-Original
    • Baseball-MLB
    • Basketball-NBA
    • Basketball-WNBA
    • Boxing
    • College-NCAA
    • Display Cases
    • Football-NFL
    • Golf-LPGA
    • Golf-PGA
    • Golf-Other
    • Hockey-NHL
    • Hockey-Other
    • Mixed Martial Arts (MMA)
    • Olympics
    • Racing-Formula 1
    • Racing-NASCAR
    • Racing-NHRA
    • Racing-Other
    • Rugby
    • Soccer
      • Tennis
      • Wrestling
      • Other Autographed Sports Mem
    • All

    • Auction

    • Buy It Now

    • Best Match
    • Time: Ending soonest
    • Time: Newly listed
    • Price + Postage: lowest first
    • Price + Postage: highest first
    • Distance: nearest first
    • List View

    134 Results

      • Autograph Authentication: Not Authenticated filter applied
      • Team: Indianapolis Colts filter applied
      Clear All
      • Not Authenticated filter applied
      • Indianapolis Colts filter applied
      • All Listings filter applied
    • Andrew Luck & T.Y. Hilton DUAL SIGNED JERSEY Nike Indianapolis Colts RARE

      Andrew Luck & T.Y. Hilton DUAL SIGNED JERSEY Nike Indianapolis Colts RARE

      RM 457.75
      RM 170.51 shipping
      SPONSORED
    • Robert Mathis Signed Football Pylon Indianapolis Colts Proof Autograph COA Auto

      Robert Mathis Signed Football Pylon Indianapolis Colts Proof Autograph COA Auto

      RM 475.97
      Was: RM 594.94
      RM 200.36 shipping
      or Best Offer
      SPONSORED
    • JEFF SATURDAY FULL SIZE FACSIMILE SIGNED COLTS FOOTBALL PITTSBURGH STEELERS wCOA

      JEFF SATURDAY FULL SIZE FACSIMILE SIGNED COLTS FOOTBALL PITTSBURGH STEELERS wCOA

      RM 160.17
      RM 237.30 shipping
      or Best Offer
      SPONSORED
    • Bill Polian Signed Football Pylon Indianapolis Colts Autograph Proof Photo Auto

      Bill Polian Signed Football Pylon Indianapolis Colts Autograph Proof Photo Auto

      RM 472.31
      Was: RM 590.41
      RM 200.27 shipping
      or Best Offer
      SPONSORED
    • Peyton Manning Signed Autographed White Panel Football Ball Colts Broncos

      Peyton Manning Signed Autographed White Panel Football Ball Colts Broncos

      RM 590.50
      RM 166.85 shipping
    • Bill Curry #50 Autographed, Signed Indianapolis Colts Riddell Mini Helmet w/Box

      Bill Curry #50 Autographed, Signed Indianapolis Colts Riddell Mini Helmet w/Box

      RM 86.93
      0 bids
      RM 131.51 shipping
      Ending Saturday at 7:48AM MYT2d 20h
    • Keith Elias Indianapolis Colts Signed & Double Matted Photograph 

      Keith Elias Indianapolis Colts Signed & Double Matted Photograph 

      RM 68.62
      0 bids
      RM 160.49 shipping
      Ending Jun 13 at 2:00AM MYT5d 14h
      or Best Offer
    • TONY DUNGY INDIANAPOLIS COLTS SIGNED AUTOGRAPHED 8X10 PHOTO SUPER BOWL CHAMPS 2

      TONY DUNGY INDIANAPOLIS COLTS SIGNED AUTOGRAPHED 8X10 PHOTO SUPER BOWL CHAMPS 2

      RM 137.32
      0 bids
      RM 128.40 shipping
      Ending Jun 17 at 9:57AM MYT9d 22h
    • Andrew Luck Autographed Indianapolis Colts Nike On Field Jersey No COA Size 44

      Andrew Luck Autographed Indianapolis Colts Nike On Field Jersey No COA Size 44

      RM 320.38
      0 bids
      RM 167.44 shipping
      Ending Today at 12:13PM MYT1h 8m
      or Best Offer
    • BERT JONES AUTOGRAPHED COLTS MINI HELMET W/INSCRIPTION

      BERT JONES AUTOGRAPHED COLTS MINI HELMET W/INSCRIPTION

      RM 411.75
      RM 208.50 shipping
      or Best Offer
    • Darius Shaquille Leonard #43 Indianapolis Colts Jersey NFL Players XL NEW w/Tags

      Darius Shaquille Leonard #43 Indianapolis Colts Jersey NFL Players XL NEW w/Tags

      RM 164.79
      RM 68.66 shipping
    • Peyton Manning Signed FedEx Advertising Card - Football Hall of Fame

      Peyton Manning Signed FedEx Advertising Card - Football Hall of Fame

      RM 343.31
      RM 116.09 shipping
    • JIM PARKER Signed Autographed 8x10 Photo COLTS HOF

      JIM PARKER Signed Autographed 8x10 Photo COLTS HOF

      RM 91.50
      RM 118.05 shipping
      or Best Offer
    • Coby Fleener Hand Signed 8X10 Photo AUTOGRAPHED  COA Indianapolis Colts To Steve

      Coby Fleener Hand Signed 8X10 Photo AUTOGRAPHED COA Indianapolis Colts To Steve

      RM 68.43
      RM 114.16 shipping
      or Best Offer
      SPONSORED
    • Coby Fleener Hand Signed 8X10 Photo AUTOGRAPHED  COA Indianapolis Colts To Steve

      Coby Fleener Hand Signed 8X10 Photo AUTOGRAPHED COA Indianapolis Colts To Steve

      RM 68.43
      RM 114.16 shipping
      or Best Offer
      SPONSORED
    • Chuck Pagano Indianapolis Colts Football 🏈

      Chuck Pagano Indianapolis Colts Football 🏈

      RM 68.66
      RM 234.46 shipping
      or Best Offer
      SPONSORED
    • TONY DUNGY Signed Autographed 8x10 Photo  Colts NFL HOF NO COA

      TONY DUNGY Signed Autographed 8x10 Photo Colts NFL HOF NO COA

      RM 45.77
      RM 116.50 shipping
    • Paul Perkins Signed NFL Football NY Giants Lions UCLA Bruin Autograph Proof Auto

      Paul Perkins Signed NFL Football NY Giants Lions UCLA Bruin Autograph Proof Auto

      RM 137.28
      0 bids
      RM 211.89 shipping
      Ending Friday at 9:45AM MYT1d 22h
      or Buy It Now
    • Bill Polian Signed NFL Football Indianapolis Colts Autograph Buffalo Auto Proof

      Bill Polian Signed NFL Football Indianapolis Colts Autograph Buffalo Auto Proof

      RM 137.28
      0 bids
      RM 211.89 shipping
      Ending Friday at 9:15AM MYT1d 22h
      or Buy It Now
    • MARSHALL FAULK 28 SIGNED AUTOGRAPHED LOS ANGELES RAMS ST. LOUIS NFL MINI HELMET

      MARSHALL FAULK 28 SIGNED AUTOGRAPHED LOS ANGELES RAMS ST. LOUIS NFL MINI HELMET

      RM 503.48
      RM 123.55 shipping
      or Best Offer
    • Phillip Dorsett Signed Football Indianapolis Colts Miami Autograph Proof Auto

      Phillip Dorsett Signed Football Indianapolis Colts Miami Autograph Proof Auto

      RM 137.28
      0 bids
      RM 211.89 shipping
      Ending Friday at 9:00AM MYT1d 21h
      or Buy It Now
    • Coby Fleener Signed NFL Football Indianapolis Colts Autograph Proof Auto COA

      Coby Fleener Signed NFL Football Indianapolis Colts Autograph Proof Auto COA

      RM 137.28
      0 bids
      RM 211.89 shipping
      Ending Friday at 9:36AM MYT1d 22h
      or Buy It Now
    • Mike Adams Signed NFL Football Indianapolis Colts Autograph Broncos Auto Proof

      Mike Adams Signed NFL Football Indianapolis Colts Autograph Broncos Auto Proof

      RM 137.28
      0 bids
      RM 211.89 shipping
      Ending Friday at 9:32AM MYT1d 22h
      or Buy It Now
    • Ahmad Bradshaw Signed NFL Football Indianapolis Colts Autograph Proof Auto

      Ahmad Bradshaw Signed NFL Football Indianapolis Colts Autograph Proof Auto

      RM 137.28
      0 bids
      RM 211.89 shipping
      Ending Friday at 9:04AM MYT1d 21h
      or Buy It Now
    • Dwight Freeney Autographed Football Indianapolis Colts Super Bowl Champ Signed

      Dwight Freeney Autographed Football Indianapolis Colts Super Bowl Champ Signed

      RM 228.65
      RM 255.70 shipping
      10 watching
    • Phillip Dorsett Signed Football Pylon Proof Indianapolis Colts Autograph Auto

      Phillip Dorsett Signed Football Pylon Proof Indianapolis Colts Autograph Auto

      RM 366.11
      Was: RM 457.61
      RM 374.71 shipping
      or Best Offer
    • Peyton Manning Autographed Football

      Peyton Manning Autographed Football

      RM 732.17
      RM 114.07 shipping
    • SIGNED INDY COLTS Andrew Luck  September 2, 2013 Sports Illustrated NO LABEL

      SIGNED INDY COLTS Andrew Luck September 2, 2013 Sports Illustrated NO LABEL

      RM 251.72
      RM 121.07 shipping
      or Best Offer
    • Chuck Pagano Signed Indianapolis Colts End Zone Football Pylon Proof Autograph

      Chuck Pagano Signed Indianapolis Colts End Zone Football Pylon Proof Autograph

      RM 362.45
      Was: RM 453.08
      RM 374.67 shipping
      or Best Offer
      SPONSORED
    • Kenny Moore II Jersey Colts Nfl Boys Size Medium

      Kenny Moore II Jersey Colts Nfl Boys Size Medium

      RM 91.50
      RM 117.37 shipping
      SPONSORED
    • Indianapolis Colts #28 Greg Toler Autographed Jersey Authentic

      Indianapolis Colts #28 Greg Toler Autographed Jersey Authentic

      RM 411.93
      RM 176.69 shipping
      or Best Offer
      SPONSORED
    • Jeff George Signed Pacific Trading Card '91 Football Card #74 Indianapolis Colts

      Jeff George Signed Pacific Trading Card '91 Football Card #74 Indianapolis Colts

      RM 100.66
      RM 173.03 shipping
      or Best Offer
      SPONSORED
    • PEYTON MANNING SIGNED SUPER BOWL MVP MINI HELMET INDIANAPOLIS COLTS BAS

      PEYTON MANNING SIGNED SUPER BOWL MVP MINI HELMET INDIANAPOLIS COLTS BAS

      RM 894.85
      Was: RM 1,052.78
      RM 173.67 shipping
      or Best Offer
    • BERT JONES AUTOGRAPHED 8 X 10 PHOTO W/INSCRIPTION

      BERT JONES AUTOGRAPHED 8 X 10 PHOTO W/INSCRIPTION

      RM 63.86
      RM 112.70 shipping
      or Best Offer
    • Dwight Freeney Signed Indianapolis Colts Autographed Jersey

      Dwight Freeney Signed Indianapolis Colts Autographed Jersey

      RM 228.83
      RM 200.68 shipping
      or Best Offer
    • Sio Moore Signed Football End Zone Pylon Indianapolis Colts Autograph Proof Auto

      Sio Moore Signed Football End Zone Pylon Indianapolis Colts Autograph Proof Auto

      RM 183.05
      0 bids
      RM 371.24 shipping
      Ending Friday at 9:00AM MYT1d 21h
      or Buy It Now
    • Peyton Manning Signed Autographed AUTO Custom Framed Wheaties Box RARE Item

      Peyton Manning Signed Autographed AUTO Custom Framed Wheaties Box RARE Item

      RM 915.04
      RM 208.60 shipping
      or Best Offer
    • Bill Polian Autographed Indianapolis Colts Goal Line Art Card Silver HOF 15171

      Bill Polian Autographed Indianapolis Colts Goal Line Art Card Silver HOF 15171

      RM 228.83
      RM 92.65 shipping
      or Best Offer
    • NIKE ANDREW LUCK Men Adult SMALL White Limited Indianapolis Colts NFL Jersey

      NIKE ANDREW LUCK Men Adult SMALL White Limited Indianapolis Colts NFL Jersey

      RM 186.62
      RM 199.81 shipping
      or Best Offer
      SPONSORED
    • Vintage Jim Harbaugh Signed Colts 8x10 Autographed Black and White Print

      Vintage Jim Harbaugh Signed Colts 8x10 Autographed Black and White Print

      RM 160.21
      RM 114.76 shipping
      or Best Offer
      SPONSORED
    • Chuck Pagano Indianapolis Colts Football 🏈

      Chuck Pagano Indianapolis Colts Football 🏈

      RM 45.73
      0 bids
      RM 234.05 shipping
      Ending Jun 13 at 9:52AM MYT5d 22h
      or Buy It Now
    • Pat Angerer Autograph Colts 16x20

      Pat Angerer Autograph Colts 16x20

      RM 274.65
      RM 723.20 shipping
      or Best Offer
    • Andrew Luck Autographed Indianapolis Colts Nike On Field Jersey No COA

      Andrew Luck Autographed Indianapolis Colts Nike On Field Jersey No COA

      RM 595.03
      RM 189.87 shipping
    • Bill Polian Autographed Indianapolis Colts Goal Line Art Card Blue HOF 15680

      Bill Polian Autographed Indianapolis Colts Goal Line Art Card Blue HOF 15680

      RM 228.83
      RM 92.65 shipping
      or Best Offer
    • Reggie Wayne WR Indianapolis Colts Autographed Riddell Mini Helmet

      Reggie Wayne WR Indianapolis Colts Autographed Riddell Mini Helmet

      RM 434.82
      0 bids
      RM 270.07 shipping
      Ending Jun 14 at 4:02PM MYT7d 4h
      or Best Offer
    • ANDRE RISON SIGNED INDIANAPOLIS COLTS CARD #7

      ANDRE RISON SIGNED INDIANAPOLIS COLTS CARD #7

      RM 36.62
      RM 91.28 shipping
      or Best Offer
    • Tony Dungy Signed Baseball ROMLB-Hall Of Fame-Indianapolis Colts

      Tony Dungy Signed Baseball ROMLB-Hall Of Fame-Indianapolis Colts

      RM 228.83
      RM 122.95 shipping
      or Best Offer
    • Indianapolis Colts Mini Helmet Autographed Signed Tony Dungy Bob Sanders Clark

      Indianapolis Colts Mini Helmet Autographed Signed Tony Dungy Bob Sanders Clark

      RM 1,029.71
      RM 130.96 shipping
      or Best Offer

    Results Pagination - Page 1

    1. 1
    2. 2
    3. 3

    Additional site navigation

    • About eBay
    • Community
    • Security Centre
    • Seller Central
    • Policies
    • Help & Contact
    • Site Map
    Copyright © 1995-2023 eBay Inc. All Rights Reserved. User Agreement, Privacy, Payments Terms of Use, Cookies and AdChoice