Andy Pettitte Autographed Baseball Cards

Shop by category

Sports Mem, Cards & Fan Shop

477 results

2019 Topps Inception Andy Pettitte Autograph /10 BGS 9.5
New (Other) · Topps
RM 1,373.73
or Best Offer
RM 144.69 shipping
New Listing2023 Topps Update Series Baseball Stars Autographs Andy Pettitte Gold/50
Pre-Owned · Topps
RM 528.38
or Best Offer
RM 97.60 shipping
New Listing/25 ANDY PETTITTE 2024 TOPPS COSMIC CHROME SCA-AP STAR COMMAND AUTO ORANGE PSA 9
New (Other) · Topps
RM 202.90
RM 88.60 shipping
8 bids
6d 5h
2017 Topps Tribute Andy Pettitte John Smoltz Dual Auto /25 Duel SP On Card
Pre-Owned · Topps
RM 528.38
or Best Offer
RM 99.29 shipping
Andy Pettitte 2020 Panini Absolute Heroes Game-Used Logo Patch Auto 1/1
Pre-Owned · Panini
RM 1,056.54
RM 93.71 shipping
2019 Topps Tier One Andy Pettitte New York Yankees Auto /60 SGC 9 Prime Perform
New (Other)
RM 380.39
or Best Offer
RM 73.76 shipping
New Listing2025 Topps Finest Baseball - Andy Pettitte #FMA-AP Finest Moments Auto Green /75
Pre-Owned · Topps
RM 317.03
or Best Offer
RM 90.54 shipping
2021 Topps Rip Mini Autographs #RIPAUAP Andy Pettitte AUTO 10/25 YANKEES
Quickest to Market for Consignment of Raw, Graded & Wax
Pre-Owned · Topps
RM 12.68
RM 85.13 shipping
2 bids
4d 16h
1993 Bowman #103 Andy Pettitte Rookie RC AUTO AUTOGRAPHED PSA AUTH
New (Other) · Topps
RM 634.01
RM 117.60 shipping
$2025 topps chrome andy pettitte orange refractor autograph /25 - Image 1 of 2$
2025 topps chrome andy pettitte orange refractor autograph /25
Pre-Owned · Topps
RM 570.65
or Best Offer
RM 97.77 shipping
$2025 Topps Finest Andy Pettitte Finest Moments Auto Refractor Yankees - Image 1 of 2$
2025 Topps Finest Andy Pettitte Finest Moments Auto Refractor Yankees
Pre-Owned · Topps
RM 95.11
RM 87.54 shipping
8 bids
14h 40m
ANDY PETTITTE BERNIE WILLIAMS YANKEES 2018 FLAWLESS GOLD DUAL SIGNATURE AUTO /5
Pre-Owned · Panini
RM 951.03
or Best Offer
RM 128.67 shipping
32 watching
2021 Topps Sterling - Sterling Strikes Auto Jersey #STAR-AP Andy Pettite /10
Pre-Owned · Topps
RM 443.84
RM 106.52 shipping
15 watching
2024 Topps Tier One Andy Pettitte Silver Ink AUTO 3/5
Pre-Owned · Topps
RM 841.17
or Best Offer
RM 105.29 shipping
2024 Topps Archives Signature Series Andy Pettitte Yankees Allen & Ginter /37
Pre-Owned · Topps
RM 295.89
or Best Offer
RM 89.91 shipping
2021 Topps Five Star - Gold Signature Autograph FSSI-AP Andy Pettitte 1/5!
Pre-Owned · Topps
RM 1,056.75
or Best Offer
RM 111.64 shipping
New Listing2024 Topps Finest - Andy Pettitte - 1993 Prototypes - Orange Ref Auto /25 Astros
Pre-Owned · Topps
RM 253.58
RM 88.68 shipping
New Listing2023 Topps Allen & Ginter Andy Pettitte Autograph Mini Auto Yankees
Pre-Owned · Topps
RM 105.63
RM 83.61 shipping
0 bids
6d 9h
New Listing2020 Topps Clearly Authentic Andy Pettitte Heritage On Card Auto /99 Yankees
Pre-Owned · Topps
RM 42.23
RM 95.91 shipping
1 bid
4d 13h
2025 Topps Finest Andy Pettitte Finest Moments Auto #FMA-AP Green Ref #50/75
Pre-Owned · Topps
RM 316.81
or Best Offer
RM 71.90 shipping
$2025 Topps Chrome Andy Pettitte Legends True Orange Refractor Auto /25 PSA 9 - Image 1 of 2$
2025 Topps Chrome Andy Pettitte Legends True Orange Refractor Auto /25 PSA 9
New (Other) · Topps
RM 845.36
or Best Offer
RM 114.93 shipping
2025 Topps Series 1 #TFAP-AP Andy Pettitte Flagship Auto Patch Relic /15 SSP
Pre-Owned · Topps
RM 549.51
or Best Offer
RM 97.39 shipping
30 watching
Two Game Used Line Up Cards Yankees Vs Orioles Joe Torre Auto Derek Jeter Matsui
Pre-Owned
RM 3,800.07
or Best Offer
RM 194.19 shipping
Topps Andy Pettitte 1/1 Auto Topps Signature Series
Pre-Owned · Topps
RM 422.70
or Best Offer
RM 93.67 shipping
0 bids
8h 22m
Andy Pettitte 2018 Topps Gypsy Queen Artist's Auto 1/1 Portrait Art Patch Tag
Pre-Owned · Topps
RM 2,109.27
or Best Offer
RM 155.81 shipping
17 watching
2022 TOPPS CLEARLY AUTHENTIC ANDY PETTITTE AUTO 100458723 PSA 8 NEW YORK YANKEES
New (Other)
RM 798.90
RM 107.24 shipping
2022 Topps Black & White #85A Andy Pettitte Player Color SSP Auto /10 Yankees
Pre-Owned · Topps
RM 528.38
or Best Offer
RM 109.65 shipping
2024 Topps Major League Material Andy Pettitte Auto Red #/25 SSP RARE Yankees
Pre-Owned · Topps
RM 528.38
or Best Offer
RM 99.25 shipping
2021 Topps Allen & Ginter Andy Pettitte Mini Framed Auto Blue SP Yankees
Pre-Owned · Topps
RM 422.57
or Best Offer
RM 94.47 shipping
2021 Topps Dynasty Andy Pettitte Patch Auto 6/10, #DAP-AP2, Arena 9.5 MT+/9 Auto
New (Other) · Topps
RM 1,479.45
or Best Offer
RM 135.14 shipping
19 watching
2024 Topps Chrome - Chrome Legends Autographs Andy Pettitte #CLA-APE (AU) /50
Pre-Owned · Topps
RM 549.47
or Best Offer
RM 97.39 shipping
1993 Classic Best ANDY PETTITTE Autographed Card RC PSA/DNA Yankees Auto
New (Other)
RM 507.20
or Best Offer
RM 102.84 shipping
1998 stadium club cosigners CS20 Alomar/Pettitte PSA 9
New (Other)
RM 376.20
RM 96.67 shipping
2022 Topps Tribute Tribute Auto Andy Pettitte /10 RED #TA-APE YANKEES
Pre-Owned · Topps
RM 422.70
or Best Offer
RM 95.70 shipping
2016 TOPPS CHROME Archives NY Yankees Andy Pettitte SIGNATURE SERIES 1/1
Pre-Owned · Topps
RM 951.08
RM 121.48 shipping
2025 Topps Finest Andy Pettitte Finest Moments Auto Green /75 #FMA-AP Yankees
Pre-Owned · Topps
RM 69.75
RM 96.76 shipping
12 bids
1d 14h
2021 Topps Archives Signature Andy Pettitte Autograph AUTO Yankees 1/1 SSP
Pre-Owned
RM 418.47
RM 93.54 shipping
0 bids
2d 1h
2025 Topps Finest Andy Pettitte Finest Moments Auto Green /75 #FMA-AP Yankees
Pre-Owned · Topps
RM 316.98
or Best Offer
RM 71.90 shipping
2018 Topps Archives Signature Series Andy Pettitte On Card Auto #’d 1/1 Yankees
2016 Allen & Ginter Mini SP #308 - Future HOF’er!!
Pre-Owned · Topps
RM 1,014.48
or Best Offer
RM 92.49 shipping
2025 Topps Sterling Andy Pettitte Relic Auto 1/1 Yankees
Pre-Owned · Topps
RM 5,283.75
or Best Offer
RM 261.06 shipping
10 watching
2025 Topps Sterling Andy Pettitte Splendor Jumbo Patch Auto /3 #TSAR-APT
Pre-Owned · Topps
RM 1,225.83
or Best Offer
RM 118.14 shipping
2021 Topps Museum Andy Pettitte Patch Auto /15! Astros! Yankees! Signature!
Pre-Owned
RM 253.58
or Best Offer
RM 89.06 shipping
ANDY PETTITTE 2018 TOPPS FINEST RED REFRACTOR AUTO AUTOGRAPH 5/5 BGS 9.5 YANKEES
New (Other) · Topps
RM 1,263.41
or Best Offer
RM 25.36 shipping
$2024 Topps Finest Andy Pettitte Auto #93A-AP Orange Refractor /25 Houston Astros - Image 1 of 3$
2024 Topps Finest Andy Pettitte Auto #93A-AP Orange Refractor /25 Houston Astros
Pre-Owned · Topps
RM 380.39
or Best Offer
RM 73.76 shipping
2020 Topps Definitive Mike Mussina Andy Pettitte Dual Auto 1/35 FIRST ONE MADE!!
RM 1,268.06
or Best Offer
RM 123.26 shipping
42 watching
$Andy Pettitte 2024 Topps Finest Baseball’s Finest Orange Refractor Auto /25 - Image 1 of 2$
Andy Pettitte 2024 Topps Finest Baseball’s Finest Orange Refractor Auto /25
Pre-Owned · Topps
RM 211.31
or Best Offer
RM 68.77 shipping
Andy Pettitte Auto PSA 9/10 - 2022 Topps Five Star Aqua /75- Yankees, Astros Ace
New (Other) · Topps
RM 629.82
or Best Offer
RM 98.02 shipping
0 bids
13h 10m
2021 Topps Clearly Authentic Autographs -Reimagining Autographs Andy Pettitte
Pre-Owned · Topps
RM 190.22
or Best Offer
RM 86.82 shipping
2022 Topps Pristine Slice Of A Star Andy Pettitte Auto /99 #SSRAP PSA 9! POP 2!
New (Other) · Topps
RM 316.98
RM 82.47 shipping
14 watching
New Listing2025 Topps Finest Andy Pettitte #FMA-AP Finest Moments Autographs
Pre-Owned · Topps
RM 13.74
RM 68.56 shipping
3 bids
6d 5h
$2024 Topps Chrome Andy Pettitte Legends Orange Refractor Auto /25 Yankees - Image 1 of 4$
2024 Topps Chrome Andy Pettitte Legends Orange Refractor Auto /25 Yankees
Pre-Owned · Topps
RM 1,056.75
RM 112.35 shipping
22 watching
2023 Topps #12P-4 CC Sabathia / Andy Pettitte One-Two Punch Dual Autographs #/25
Pre-Owned · Topps
RM 634.05
or Best Offer
RM 81.24 shipping
2017 Bowman Chrome Andy Pettitte MLB Draft History Auto #'ed 51/99 BGS 9.5
New (Other) · Topps
RM 727.04
or Best Offer
RM 109.14 shipping
PETTITE/WILLIAMS/POSADA 2020 TOPPS TRIPLE THREADS TRIPLE PATCH AUTOGRAPH! #23/36
Pre-Owned · Topps
RM 1,010.25
RM 92.36 shipping
39 watching
ANDY PETTITTE/SANDY ALOMAR 1998 TOPPS STADIUM CLUB DUAL AUTOGRAPH AUTOS!
Pre-Owned · Topps
RM 169.04
RM 67.55 shipping
2024 Topps Diamond Icons Andy Pettitte Auto 9/10
Pre-Owned · Topps
RM 317.03
or Best Offer
RM 89.82 shipping
2012 Topps Tier One #CPA-AP Andy Pettitte Crowd Pleaser AUTO 08/10 Black Yankees
Pre-Owned · Topps
RM 739.73
or Best Offer
RM 117.55 shipping
Andy Pettitte Topps Triple Threads Game Used Patch Auto Relic /36 MLB NY Yankees
Pre-Owned · Topps
RM 633.84
or Best Offer
RM 102.34 shipping
Andy Pettitte 2024 Topps Dynasty Autograph Silver #DAP-APE1 GAME USED AUTO #4/5
Pre-Owned · Topps
RM 2,113.46
or Best Offer
RM 161.64 shipping
Andy Pettitte 2005 Donruss Playoff Signed Baseball Card PSA/DNA Certified 27/100
Pre-Owned · Donruss
RM 693.23
or Best Offer
RM 83.02 shipping

Andy Pettitte Autographed Baseball Cards

Shop by category

477 results

2019 Topps Inception Andy Pettitte Autograph /10 BGS 9.5

New Listing2023 Topps Update Series Baseball Stars Autographs Andy Pettitte Gold/50

New Listing/25 ANDY PETTITTE 2024 TOPPS COSMIC CHROME SCA-AP STAR COMMAND AUTO ORANGE PSA 9

2017 Topps Tribute Andy Pettitte John Smoltz Dual Auto /25 Duel SP On Card

Andy Pettitte 2020 Panini Absolute Heroes Game-Used Logo Patch Auto 1/1

2019 Topps Tier One Andy Pettitte New York Yankees Auto /60 SGC 9 Prime Perform

New Listing2025 Topps Finest Baseball - Andy Pettitte #FMA-AP Finest Moments Auto Green /75

2021 Topps Rip Mini Autographs #RIPAUAP Andy Pettitte AUTO 10/25 YANKEES

1993 Bowman #103 Andy Pettitte Rookie RC AUTO AUTOGRAPHED PSA AUTH

2025 topps chrome andy pettitte orange refractor autograph /25

2025 Topps Finest Andy Pettitte Finest Moments Auto Refractor Yankees

ANDY PETTITTE BERNIE WILLIAMS YANKEES 2018 FLAWLESS GOLD DUAL SIGNATURE AUTO /5

2021 Topps Sterling - Sterling Strikes Auto Jersey #STAR-AP Andy Pettite /10

2024 Topps Tier One Andy Pettitte Silver Ink AUTO 3/5

2024 Topps Archives Signature Series Andy Pettitte Yankees Allen & Ginter /37

2021 Topps Five Star - Gold Signature Autograph FSSI-AP Andy Pettitte 1/5!

New Listing2024 Topps Finest - Andy Pettitte - 1993 Prototypes - Orange Ref Auto /25 Astros

New Listing2023 Topps Allen & Ginter Andy Pettitte Autograph Mini Auto Yankees

New Listing2020 Topps Clearly Authentic Andy Pettitte Heritage On Card Auto /99 Yankees

2025 Topps Finest Andy Pettitte Finest Moments Auto #FMA-AP Green Ref #50/75

2025 Topps Chrome Andy Pettitte Legends True Orange Refractor Auto /25 PSA 9

2025 Topps Series 1 #TFAP-AP Andy Pettitte Flagship Auto Patch Relic /15 SSP

Two Game Used Line Up Cards Yankees Vs Orioles Joe Torre Auto Derek Jeter Matsui

Topps Andy Pettitte 1/1 Auto Topps Signature Series

Andy Pettitte 2018 Topps Gypsy Queen Artist's Auto 1/1 Portrait Art Patch Tag

2022 TOPPS CLEARLY AUTHENTIC ANDY PETTITTE AUTO 100458723 PSA 8 NEW YORK YANKEES

2022 Topps Black & White #85A Andy Pettitte Player Color SSP Auto /10 Yankees

2024 Topps Major League Material Andy Pettitte Auto Red #/25 SSP RARE Yankees

2021 Topps Allen & Ginter Andy Pettitte Mini Framed Auto Blue SP Yankees

2021 Topps Dynasty Andy Pettitte Patch Auto 6/10, #DAP-AP2, Arena 9.5 MT+/9 Auto

2024 Topps Chrome - Chrome Legends Autographs Andy Pettitte #CLA-APE (AU) /50

1993 Classic Best ANDY PETTITTE Autographed Card RC PSA/DNA Yankees Auto

1998 stadium club cosigners CS20 Alomar/Pettitte PSA 9

2022 Topps Tribute Tribute Auto Andy Pettitte /10 RED #TA-APE YANKEES

2016 TOPPS CHROME Archives NY Yankees Andy Pettitte SIGNATURE SERIES 1/1

2025 Topps Finest Andy Pettitte Finest Moments Auto Green /75 #FMA-AP Yankees

2021 Topps Archives Signature Andy Pettitte Autograph AUTO Yankees 1/1 SSP

2025 Topps Finest Andy Pettitte Finest Moments Auto Green /75 #FMA-AP Yankees

2018 Topps Archives Signature Series Andy Pettitte On Card Auto #’d 1/1 Yankees

2025 Topps Sterling Andy Pettitte Relic Auto 1/1 Yankees

2025 Topps Sterling Andy Pettitte Splendor Jumbo Patch Auto /3 #TSAR-APT

2021 Topps Museum Andy Pettitte Patch Auto /15! Astros! Yankees! Signature!

ANDY PETTITTE 2018 TOPPS FINEST RED REFRACTOR AUTO AUTOGRAPH 5/5 BGS 9.5 YANKEES

2024 Topps Finest Andy Pettitte Auto #93A-AP Orange Refractor /25 Houston Astros

2020 Topps Definitive Mike Mussina Andy Pettitte Dual Auto 1/35 FIRST ONE MADE!!

Andy Pettitte 2024 Topps Finest Baseball’s Finest Orange Refractor Auto /25

Andy Pettitte Auto PSA 9/10 - 2022 Topps Five Star Aqua /75- Yankees, Astros Ace

2021 Topps Clearly Authentic Autographs -Reimagining Autographs Andy Pettitte

2022 Topps Pristine Slice Of A Star Andy Pettitte Auto /99 #SSRAP PSA 9! POP 2!

New Listing2025 Topps Finest Andy Pettitte #FMA-AP Finest Moments Autographs

2024 Topps Chrome Andy Pettitte Legends Orange Refractor Auto /25 Yankees

2023 Topps #12P-4 CC Sabathia / Andy Pettitte One-Two Punch Dual Autographs #/25

2017 Bowman Chrome Andy Pettitte MLB Draft History Auto #'ed 51/99 BGS 9.5

PETTITE/WILLIAMS/POSADA 2020 TOPPS TRIPLE THREADS TRIPLE PATCH AUTOGRAPH! #23/36

ANDY PETTITTE/SANDY ALOMAR 1998 TOPPS STADIUM CLUB DUAL AUTOGRAPH AUTOS!

2024 Topps Diamond Icons Andy Pettitte Auto 9/10

2012 Topps Tier One #CPA-AP Andy Pettitte Crowd Pleaser AUTO 08/10 Black Yankees

Andy Pettitte Topps Triple Threads Game Used Patch Auto Relic /36 MLB NY Yankees

Andy Pettitte 2024 Topps Dynasty Autograph Silver #DAP-APE1 GAME USED AUTO #4/5

Andy Pettitte 2005 Donruss Playoff Signed Baseball Card PSA/DNA Certified 27/100

More to explore