Allie Reynolds Baseball Sports Trading Cards & Accessories ungraded

Shop by category

Sports Mem, Cards & Fan Shop

2,138 results

1952 Star-Cal Decals #84-A: Allie Reynolds & Vic Raschi
Pre-Owned
RM 1,124.09
or Best Offer
RM 123.17 shipping
1953 H-O Instant Oatmeal Allie Reynolds Record New York Yankees with Envelope
Pre-Owned
RM 1,056.71
or Best Offer
RM 93.71 shipping
1948 BOWMAN #14 ALLIE REYNOLDS ROOKIE NEW YORK YANKEES LOW GRADE FAIR
Pre-Owned · Bowman
RM 21.09
RM 92.99 shipping
0 bids
5d 8h
1952 TOPPS ALLIE REYNOLDS THE CARD IS A LAMINATED CARD #67
Pre-Owned · Topps
RM 8.45
RM 71.27 shipping
0 bids
10h 20m
1953 Topps Allie Reynolds New York Yankees #141 C36
Pre-Owned
RM 6.59
RM 70.17 shipping
3 bids
3d 9h
ALLIE REYNOLDS yankees 1953 TOPPS #141
Pre-Owned · Topps
RM 42.06
RM 16.44 shipping
VINTAGE ALLIE REYNOLDS SIGNED NEW YORK YANKEES J.D. MCCARTHY POSTCARD EX
Pre-Owned
RM 33.77
RM 92.99 shipping
0 bids
4d 3h
1952 TOPPS #67 ALLIE REYNOLDS GOOD
Pre-Owned · Topps
RM 17.96
RM 69.41 shipping
4 bids
3d 9h
1955 Bowman #201 Allie Reynolds New York Yankees - Centered
Pre-Owned · Bowman
RM 31.70
or Best Offer
RM 67.46 shipping
0 bids
23h 41m
1952 Topps ALLIE REYNOLDS #67 - 2021 Topps Tribute Framed Buyback #d 1/1 - NYY
Pre-Owned · Topps
RM 1,056.54
or Best Offer
RM 112.69 shipping
0 bids
2d 5h
ALLIE REYNOLDS yankees 1953 BOWMAN COLOR #68 FAIR
Pre-Owned · Bowman
RM 46.54
RM 16.44 shipping
1955 Bowman Allie Reynolds #201 NY Yankees Low Grade (Poor Filler) Tape
Pre-Owned · Bowman
RM 4.18
RM 65.81 shipping
0 bids
7d 9h
1951 Berk Ross Doubles Ralph Kiner 3-1 Allie Reynolds 3-3
Pre-Owned
RM 295.85
RM 88.18 shipping
2008 Upper Deck Yankee Stadium Legacy Allie Reynolds #YSL1886. *B5
Pre-Owned · Upper Deck
RM 5.03
RM 65.81 shipping
2011 Topps Prime Derek Jeter card #PNR4
Pre-Owned · Topps
RM 20.08
or Best Offer
RM 68.73 shipping
1950 DRAKE'S COOKIES #28 ALLIE REYNOLDS NEW YORK YANKEES PITCHER 3RD YEAR WOW
Pre-Owned
RM 1,479.41
or Best Offer
RM 118.23 shipping
1953 Bowman Color Allie Reynolds NY Yankees #68 POOR (Low grade, Filler)
Pre-Owned · Bowman
RM 4.18
RM 65.81 shipping
0 bids
7d 9h
1955 Bowman Allie Reynolds #201
Pre-Owned · Bowman
RM 21.09
RM 68.77 shipping
0 bids
6h 44m
2002 Topps Chrome '52 Reprints #52R9 Allie Reynolds - New York Yankees
Pre-Owned · Topps
RM 4.18
or Best Offer
RM 68.56 shipping
0 bids
6d 10h
New Listing1988 Pacific Allie Reynolds Signed Card New York Yankees Autograph
Pre-Owned · Pacific
RM 12.64
RM 67.17 shipping
0 bids
6d 7h
1952 Topps Allie Reynolds Baseball Card No.67 New York Yankees Red Back
Pre-Owned · Topps
RM 84.50
or Best Offer
RM 70.63 shipping
1948 Bowman #14 Allie Reynolds GD [Front looks EX] a
Pre-Owned · Bowman
RM 147.95
or Best Offer
RM 66.91 shipping
Barry Bonds 1996 Pacific Collection #P-65 San Francisco Giants
Pre-Owned · Pacific
RM 12.22
or Best Offer
RM 67.08 shipping
0 bids
20h 39m
1952 Topps Baseball Cards Complete Your Set 1 - 487
Pre-Owned · Topps
RM 333.93
RM 93.33 shipping
Allie Reynolds PSA DNA Signed 1953 Bowman Color Autograph
New (Other) · Bowman
RM 410.02
or Best Offer
RM 94.73 shipping
1955 Bowman Baseball - Pick A Card - Cards 161-320
Pre-Owned
RM 14.75 to RM 1,183.52
RM 70.46 shipping
1952 TOPPS BASEBALL (EX) # 67 ALLIE REYNOLDS (RB) - NEW YORK YANKEES
Pre-Owned · Topps
RM 105.63
or Best Offer
RM 74.10 shipping
0 bids
2d 1h
(4) 2001 TOPPS ARCHIVES LEE SMITH, Luis Aparicio, Allie Reynolds, Nellie Fox
Pre-Owned · Topps
RM 7.19
RM 67.00 shipping
0 bids
5d 7h
1953 Topps #141 Allie Reynolds Authentic Autographed Card (CAS Cert.)
Pre-Owned · Topps
RM 317.03
RM 95.15 shipping
ALLIE REYNOLDS - LEGENDARY YANKEES PLAYER - COLLECTABLE COIN SET
Pre-Owned
RM 105.21
or Best Offer
RM 86.32 shipping
2014 Bowman Derek Jeter card #1
Pre-Owned · Topps
RM 12.64
or Best Offer
RM 62.94 shipping
Allie Reynolds Card New York Yankees Hero Decks Playing Card
Pre-Owned
RM 42.23
or Best Offer
RM 63.79 shipping
ALLIE REYNOLDS 2020 HISTORIC AUTOGRAPHS HALF CENTURY CUT AUTO 1949 BOWMAN YANKEE
Pre-Owned
RM 376.20
or Best Offer
RM 96.88 shipping
1954 Bowman Allie Reynolds #113 ~Yankees ~Poor
Pre-Owned · Bowman
RM 12.68
or Best Offer
RM 68.52 shipping
0 bids
5d 1h
1950 Bowman - Allie Reynolds #138
Pre-Owned · Bowman
RM 29.59
RM 69.03 shipping
0 bids
3d 12h
1952 Topps #67 Allie Reynolds Red Back - New York Yankees VG-VGEX
Pre-Owned · Topps
RM 126.77
or Best Offer
RM 16.91 shipping
1952 Topps Baseball Card #67 Allie Reynolds NY YANKEES GREAT! Nice see scan
Pre-Owned · Topps
RM 46.96
or Best Offer
RM 68.98 shipping
0 bids
1d 9h
Allie Reynolds 2002 Topps 1952 World Series 50th Anniversary Gold #52R-9 Yankees
Pre-Owned · Topps
RM 4.61
RM 68.27 shipping
0 bids
5d 11h
$2000 Upper Deck Ionix #B2 DEREK JETER Bio Rhythm Refractor New York YANKEES - Image 1 of 2$
2000 Upper Deck Ionix #B2 DEREK JETER Bio Rhythm Refractor New York YANKEES
Pre-Owned · Upper Deck
RM 63.41
or Best Offer
RM 64.42 shipping
ALLIE REYNOLDS 1952 TOPPS #67 PSA 1
Pre-Owned · Topps
RM 422.70
or Best Offer
RM 95.95 shipping
Allie Reynolds New York Yankees 1991 Topps Archives 1953 T Reprint BLANK BACK
Pre-Owned
RM 25.32
or Best Offer
RM 12.68 shipping
2002 Topps 1952 World Series Highlights #52WS-7 Allie Reynolds Ed Lopat
Pre-Owned · Topps
RM 4.18
RM 71.10 shipping
0 bids
1d 22h
2009 UD SP LEGENDARY ALLIE REYNOLDS CUT SIGNATURE AUTO # 17/39 YANKEES!!
Pre-Owned · Upper Deck
RM 338.12
or Best Offer
RM 103.39 shipping
1952 Topps Baseball Cards #2 thru #299 - U Pick RESTOCKED 6/27/25 & DISCOUNTED
Pre-Owned · Topps
RM 16.91 to RM 1,246.75
RM 88.98 shipping
Allie Reynolds 2011 Donruss Limited Cuts 3/14 Sealed By Panini Superchief
Pre-Owned · Donruss
RM 295.85
or Best Offer
RM 92.36 shipping
1952 Topps Allie Reynolds #67 Black Back, Well Centered, No Creases, Great Color
Pre-Owned · Topps
RM 211.35
RM 98.32 shipping
1948 Bowman # 14 Allie Reynolds Rookie Excellent TheVintageCards
Pre-Owned · Bowman
RM 126.81
or Best Offer
RM 93.75 shipping
Allie Reynolds Beckett BAS Vintage Signed 1951 Bowman Autograph
New (Other)
RM 439.61
or Best Offer
RM 95.61 shipping
1951 topps red backs baseball cards, complete your set
Pre-Owned · Topps
RM 33.82 to RM 414.25
RM 70.63 shipping
Allie Reynolds 1948 Bowman RC #14 New York Yankees
Pre-Owned
RM 105.63
RM 65.69 shipping
1948 BOWMAN # 14 ALLIE REYNOLDS RC INV J6944
Pre-Owned · Bowman
RM 211.31
or Best Offer
RM 63.41 shipping
1953 Topps Yankees #87 Lopat, #141 Reynolds
Pre-Owned · Topps
RM 105.68
RM 84.33 shipping
0 bids
3d 21h
1983 Topps Baseball 1952 Reprint Allie Reynolds New York Yankees #67
Pre-Owned · Topps
RM 9.11
or Best Offer
RM 15.13 shipping
Allie Reynolds Beckett BAS Signed 1975-76 Great Plains Greats Autograph
New (Other)
RM 202.90
or Best Offer
RM 88.64 shipping
1953 Bowman #68 Allie Reynolds Signed Authentic Autograph New York Yankees
Pre-Owned · Bowman
RM 338.12
or Best Offer
RM 97.86 shipping
1949 Bowman Baseball Allie Reynold #114 New York Yankees -Excellent Condition
Pre-Owned · Bowman
RM 262.07
RM 86.99 shipping
1950 Bowman #138 Allie Reynolds
Pre-Owned · Bowman
RM 25.36
or Best Offer
RM 67.51 shipping
1991 Topps '53 Archives Baseball Singles (1-250) - You Choose
Pre-Owned
RM 4.61
RM 10.57 shipping
Allie Reynolds NY Yankees (d.94) 1982 TCMA Baseballs Greatest Card Autograph JSA
Pre-Owned · TCMA
RM 211.31
or Best Offer
RM 68.77 shipping
2001 Upper Deck Hall Of Famers Ernie Banks card #ES7 Cubs
Pre-Owned · Upper Deck
RM 14.75
RM 62.98 shipping

Allie Reynolds Baseball Sports Trading Cards & Accessories ungraded

Shop by category

2,138 results

1952 Star-Cal Decals #84-A: Allie Reynolds & Vic Raschi

1953 H-O Instant Oatmeal Allie Reynolds Record New York Yankees with Envelope

1948 BOWMAN #14 ALLIE REYNOLDS ROOKIE NEW YORK YANKEES LOW GRADE FAIR

1952 TOPPS ALLIE REYNOLDS THE CARD IS A LAMINATED CARD #67

1953 Topps Allie Reynolds New York Yankees #141 C36

ALLIE REYNOLDS yankees 1953 TOPPS #141

VINTAGE ALLIE REYNOLDS SIGNED NEW YORK YANKEES J.D. MCCARTHY POSTCARD EX

1952 TOPPS #67 ALLIE REYNOLDS GOOD

1955 Bowman #201 Allie Reynolds New York Yankees - Centered

1952 Topps ALLIE REYNOLDS #67 - 2021 Topps Tribute Framed Buyback #d 1/1 - NYY

ALLIE REYNOLDS yankees 1953 BOWMAN COLOR #68 FAIR

1955 Bowman Allie Reynolds #201 NY Yankees Low Grade (Poor Filler) Tape

1951 Berk Ross Doubles Ralph Kiner 3-1 Allie Reynolds 3-3

2008 Upper Deck Yankee Stadium Legacy Allie Reynolds #YSL1886. *B5

2011 Topps Prime Derek Jeter card #PNR4

1950 DRAKE'S COOKIES #28 ALLIE REYNOLDS NEW YORK YANKEES PITCHER 3RD YEAR WOW

1953 Bowman Color Allie Reynolds NY Yankees #68 POOR (Low grade, Filler)

1955 Bowman Allie Reynolds #201

2002 Topps Chrome '52 Reprints #52R9 Allie Reynolds - New York Yankees

New Listing1988 Pacific Allie Reynolds Signed Card New York Yankees Autograph

1952 Topps Allie Reynolds Baseball Card No.67 New York Yankees Red Back

1948 Bowman #14 Allie Reynolds GD [Front looks EX] a

Barry Bonds 1996 Pacific Collection #P-65 San Francisco Giants

1952 Topps Baseball Cards Complete Your Set 1 - 487

Allie Reynolds PSA DNA Signed 1953 Bowman Color Autograph

1955 Bowman Baseball - Pick A Card - Cards 161-320

1952 TOPPS BASEBALL (EX) # 67 ALLIE REYNOLDS (RB) - NEW YORK YANKEES

(4) 2001 TOPPS ARCHIVES LEE SMITH, Luis Aparicio, Allie Reynolds, Nellie Fox

1953 Topps #141 Allie Reynolds Authentic Autographed Card (CAS Cert.)

ALLIE REYNOLDS - LEGENDARY YANKEES PLAYER - COLLECTABLE COIN SET

2014 Bowman Derek Jeter card #1

Allie Reynolds Card New York Yankees Hero Decks Playing Card

ALLIE REYNOLDS 2020 HISTORIC AUTOGRAPHS HALF CENTURY CUT AUTO 1949 BOWMAN YANKEE

1954 Bowman Allie Reynolds #113 ~Yankees ~Poor

1950 Bowman - Allie Reynolds #138

1952 Topps #67 Allie Reynolds Red Back - New York Yankees VG-VGEX

1952 Topps Baseball Card #67 Allie Reynolds NY YANKEES GREAT! Nice see scan

Allie Reynolds 2002 Topps 1952 World Series 50th Anniversary Gold #52R-9 Yankees

2000 Upper Deck Ionix #B2 DEREK JETER Bio Rhythm Refractor New York YANKEES

ALLIE REYNOLDS 1952 TOPPS #67 PSA 1

Allie Reynolds New York Yankees 1991 Topps Archives 1953 T Reprint BLANK BACK

2002 Topps 1952 World Series Highlights #52WS-7 Allie Reynolds Ed Lopat

2009 UD SP LEGENDARY ALLIE REYNOLDS CUT SIGNATURE AUTO # 17/39 YANKEES!!

1952 Topps Baseball Cards #2 thru #299 - U Pick RESTOCKED 6/27/25 & DISCOUNTED

Allie Reynolds 2011 Donruss Limited Cuts 3/14 Sealed By Panini Superchief

1952 Topps Allie Reynolds #67 Black Back, Well Centered, No Creases, Great Color

1948 Bowman # 14 Allie Reynolds Rookie Excellent TheVintageCards

Allie Reynolds Beckett BAS Vintage Signed 1951 Bowman Autograph

1951 topps red backs baseball cards, complete your set

Allie Reynolds 1948 Bowman RC #14 New York Yankees

1948 BOWMAN # 14 ALLIE REYNOLDS RC INV J6944

1953 Topps Yankees #87 Lopat, #141 Reynolds

1983 Topps Baseball 1952 Reprint Allie Reynolds New York Yankees #67

Allie Reynolds Beckett BAS Signed 1975-76 Great Plains Greats Autograph

1953 Bowman #68 Allie Reynolds Signed Authentic Autograph New York Yankees

1949 Bowman Baseball Allie Reynold #114 New York Yankees -Excellent Condition

1950 Bowman #138 Allie Reynolds

1991 Topps '53 Archives Baseball Singles (1-250) - You Choose

Allie Reynolds NY Yankees (d.94) 1982 TCMA Baseballs Greatest Card Autograph JSA

2001 Upper Deck Hall Of Famers Ernie Banks card #ES7 Cubs

More to explore